Jewish World Review April 10, 2001 / 17 Nissan, 5761
Enduring Arthur Miller: Oh, the Humanities!
HOLLYWOOD'S 1929 production of "The Taming of the Shrew" carried this credit line: "By William Shakespeare, with additional dialogue by Sam Taylor." Caricature cannot cope with some cultural episodes, such as Arthur Miller's Jefferson Lecture March 26, which has to be seen to be disbelieved.
It should be, but is not, available at www.neh.gov/news/miller/index.html. Miller is denying public access to this lecture because, incredibly, he plans to publish it in a magazine. The sooner a magazine makes that mistake, the better, because the lecture is a timely demonstration of the trivialization of the National Endowment for the Humanities. It is timely because Bill Ferris, chairman of the NEH that ludicrously miscast Miller as the Jefferson lecturer, wants to stay in his job. He should have extended to President Bush the courtesy of resigning, as NEH chair Lynne Cheney did when President Clinton took office. Instead, he is seeking a second term. His current one expires in November.
The NEH says the annual Jefferson Lecture "recognizes an individual who has made significant scholarly contributions to the humanities." Miller is not a scholar. But, then, neither was Ferris's choice for the 1999 lecturer -- his patron, Bill Clinton (who declined the invitation when scholars protested).
Since Lionel Trilling's inaugural lecture in 1972, other lecturers have included Robert Penn Warren, Saul Bellow, Barbara Tuchman, Erik Erikson, Leszek Kolakowski, Edward Shils, Bernard Bailyn, Gertrude Himmelfarb, C. Vann Woodward, Walker Percy, Robert Nisbet, Forrest McDonald, Sidney Hook, Cleanth Brooks, Jaroslav Pelikan, Stephen Toulmin, James M. McPherson, Robert Conquest and Bernard M.W. Knox. There have been remarkably few lapses from the generally exalted standards of the lectureship, and never have those standards been as traduced as they were by Miller's political rant about the presidential election, the inadequacies of Ronald Reagan, the hairdos of television news anchors, President Bush's public speaking and the bulletin that FDR was the only president Miller felt "confident" about calling president.
The most embarrassing aspect was that Miller's self-absorption renders him immune to embarrassment. But, then, Ferris's NEH is similarly immune, making grants for a documentary film about the Miss America Pageant, for a feminist film on the historical significance of Cinderella and the like.
It is no accident that both Ferris and Bill Ivey, chairman of the National Endowment for the Arts, are folklorists. Aren't we all?
The NEA has said that art includes "the expressive behaviors of ordinary people" (even "dinner-table arrangements" and "playtime activities" and "work practices"). Ferris, not to be outdone in the egalitarianism sweepstakes, says the NEH's business is culture, and culture means " 'lifestyle' and a lot more." How much more? "Everything." Which means that something in all 435 congressional districts can be subsidized. No wonder Ferris was confirmed in 1997 without controversy -- indeed, without hearings.
No one becomes unpopular in Washington by populist pandering, such as this Ferrisism: "Today the lives of ordinary American people have assumed a place beside volumes of European classics in the humanities." However, the NEH's mission should be to nurture that which is neither spontaneous nor ubiquitous -- excellence, a rarity.
President Bush wisely economizes presidential leadership by focusing on a few big issues, so he probably has scant, if any, interest in who heads the NEH. Besides, Ferris is from Mississippi and enjoys the support of Mississippi's two Republican senators, Trent Lott and Thad Cochran. However, early evidence of Bush's sound instincts on cultural questions was the fact that he strongly disliked Yale's ambiance in the 1960s. And a Yale man, Donald Kagan, would be ideal as Ferris's replacement.
Kagan, an eminent professor of history and classics, is a former dean of Yale College with a luminous record of scholarship and an appropriately unenthralled understanding of what happened on college campuses in the 1960s, when he witnessed Cornell's degradation, and the continuing injury done to campuses since then. Kagan loves teaching, and is absorbed in finishing a one-volume history of the Peloponnesian wars, a distillation for general readers of his four-volume scholarly history. So he would be reluctant, perhaps to the point of declining, to come to the NEH.
This dedication to scholarship marks him as exactly the sort of person required for the restoration of the NEH's seriousness. And if he cannot be enticed, Bush can find someone like him among the saving remnant of scholars who continue to resist the closing -- and emptying -- of the American mind. By changing the focus of the NEH, Bush could help change the tone of academic life, to the discomfiture of his cultured despisers. Pleasant
Comment on JWR contributor George Will's column by clicking here.
04/06/01: Reading China
03/30/01: The Senate's Comic Opera
03/26/01: A second decade of economic trouble?
03/22/01: McCainism, the McCarthyism of today's "progressives"
03/19/01: Skirting what the First Amendment says
03/16/01: The SAT's thankless task
03/12/01: Fending Off the Speech Police
03/08/01: Democrat turnabout?
03/05/01: Let us hope not!
03/01/01: Duck! Our racial and ethnic spoils system is spinning out of control
02/26/01: Common Sense and the Constitution
02/22/01: Brooklyn's Artsy Dodgers
02/20/01: Whose surplus is it, anyway?
02/16/01: A truly inclusive holiday
02/12/01: Within the realm of Bush's tax cut
02/08/01: A season spoiled
02/05/01: Keeping faith behind initiatives
02/01/01: Tall order for a few federal dollars
01/29/01: You ain't seen nothin' yet
01/26/01: 'Art' Unburdened by Excellence
01/22/01: The monkey that could mean the end
01/19/01: The real enemy in the drug war
01/15/01: Congress just isn't big enough
01/12/01: Clinton's mark
01/08/01: All that is jazz
01/04/01: Bush's picks reveal Right attitude
01/02/01: Prosperity in perspective
12/28/00: Soft landing in a spoiled nation
12/26/00: When laws replace common sense
12/21/00: Beware the 'Bipartisanship'
12/18/00: ... A Brief Moment
12/13/00: Judicial activism on trial
12/11/00: Truth optional
12/06/00: A Chastened Court
12/01/00: Counting on some slippery language
11/28/00: Florida's rogue court
11/27/00: This willful court
11/22/00: Ferocity gap
11/17/00: Slow-motion larceny
11/13/00: Gore, Hungry for Power
11/09/00: No, the System Worked
11/06/00: The case for Bush
11/03/00: The Framers' Electoral wisdom
10/30/00: Political astronomy
10/27/00: Candidates condescending
10/23/00: No Partners For Peace
10/20/00: Talking peace with thugs
10/11/00: A feast of retreats
10/10/00: .. And what's gotten into the Danes?
10/05/00: The Agony of Debate
10/02/00: Senate Canvas
09/28/00: Milosevic: Not Another Saddam
09/25/00: Blaming the Voters
09/22/00: Saying No to the Euro
09/18/00: Farewell, Mr. Moynihan
09/14/00: When 'Choice' Rules
09/12/00: Colombia Illusions
09/08/00: Will He Spend It All?
09/04/00: Back in the U.S.S.R.
08/31/00: Stonewalling School Reform
08/28/00: Uphill for a California Republican
08/24/00: Sauerkraut Ice Cream
08/21/00: The Partial-Birth Censors
08/18/00: A Party to Prosperity
08/14/00: The National Scold on the Stump
08/10/00: The Thinking Person's Choice
08/07/00: The GOP of Powell And Rice
08/03/00: Panic in the Gore Camp
07/27/00: . . . Both Radical and Reassuring
07/06/00: Harry Potter: A Wizard's Return
07/03/00: Recalling the Revolution
06/29/00: An Act of Judicial Infamy
06/26/00: Life, Liberty and ... the Pursuit of Foxes
06/21/00: Fumble on Prayer
06/19/00: The unified field theory of culture
06/15/00: Schools Beset by Lawyers And Shrinks
06/12/00: Missile Defense Charade
06/07/00: The Grandparent Dissent
06/05/00: Liberal Condescension
06/01/00: Great Awakenings
05/30/00: Suddenly Social Security
05/25/00: Forget Values, Let's Talk Virtues
05/22/00: AlGore the Hysteric
05/15/00: Majestic Avenue
05/11/00: Just How Irrational Is the Exuberance?
05/08/00: Home-Run Glut
05/04/00: A Lesson Plan for Gore
05/01/00: The Hijacking of the Primaries
04/28/00: The Raid in Little Havana
04/24/00: Tinkering Again
04/17/00: A Judgment Against Hate
04/13/00: Tech- Stock Joy Ride
04/10/00: What the bobos are buying
04/06/00: A must-read horror book
04/03/00: 'Improving' the Bill of Rights
03/30/00: Sleaze, The Sequel
03/27/00: How new 'rights' will destroy freedom
03/23/00: Death and the Liveliest Writing
03/20/00: Powell is Dubyah's best bet
03/16/00: Free to Be Politically Intense
03/13/00: Runnin', Gunnin' and Gambling
03/09/00: And Now Back to Republican Business
03/06/00: As the Clock Runs Out on Bradley
03/02/00: Island of Equal Protection
02/28/00: . . . The Right Response
02/24/00: Federal Swelling
02/22/00: Greenspan Tweaks
02/17/00: Crucial Carolina (and Montana and . . .)
02/10/00: McCain's Distortions
02/10/00: The Disciplining of Austria
02/07/00: Free to Speak, Free to Give
02/02/00: Conservatives in a Changing Market
01/31/00: America's true unity day
01/27/00: For the Voter Who Can't Be Bothered
01/25/00: The FBI and the golden age of child pornography
01/20/00: Scruples and Science
01/18/00: Bradley: Better for What Ails Us
01/13/00: O'Brian Rules the Waves
01/10/00: Patron of the boom
01/06/00: In Cactus Jack's Footsteps
01/03/00: The long year
12/31/99: A Stark Perspective On a Radical Century
12/20/99: Soldiers' Snapshots of the Hell They Created
12/16/99: Star-Crossed Banner
12/13/99: Hubert Humphrey Wannabe
12/09/99: Stupidity in Seattle
12/06/99: Bradley's most important vote
12/03/99: Boys will be boys --- or you can always drug 'em
12/01/99: Confidence in the Gore Camp
11/29/99: Busing's End
11/22/99: When We Enjoyed Politics
11/18/99: Ever the Global Gloomster
11/15/99: The Politics of Sanctimony
11/10/99: Risks of Restraining
11/08/99: Willie Brown Besieged
11/04/99: One-House Town
11/01/99: Crack and Cant
10/28/99: Tax Break for the Yachting Class
10/25/99: Ready for The Big Leagues?
10/21/99: Where honor and responsibility still exist
10/18/99: Is Free Speech Only for the Media?
10/14/99: A Beguiling Amateur
10/11/99: Money in Politics: Where's the Problem?
10/08/99: Soft Thinking On Soft Money
© 2000, Washington Post Writer's Group