Jewish World Review April 21, 2004 /30 Nissan, 5764
Beware of an old man in a hurry
"Beware of an old man in a hurry." Palestinian leaders and people would be wise to keep that English maxim in mind right now. Ariel Sharon, the old Israeli bulldozer, has his policy rig in overdrive. And, with President Bush riding shotgun, Sharon is driving roughshod over Palestinian fantasies on his way to a unilateral peace.
For a generation Israel, America and Europe have been seeking peace between the Jews and the Palestinians on the theory of good faith negotiations between the parties. But Mr. Arafat's rejection in 2000 of the Clinton-brokered best deal possible, compounded by the subsequent policy of suicide bombing Israeli civilians in Israel-proper, forced Old Man Sharon to think anew of how to gain peace for his people. Now in his 76th year, Prime Minister Sharon has no time to waste and neither do the Palestinians if they want to have any role in their own imminent destiny.
Sharon is consolidating Israel's position geographically, as he is consolidating his own political position domestically. He has been well on his way to the construction of a complete fence or wall that will protect Israel plus its major settlements on the West Bank. Now he is yielding Israeli settlements in Gaza and outriding settlements on the West Bank. In other words, thinking like a general, he is withdrawing from undefendable salients. The objective will be an Israeli fortress that can stand until such time as the Palestinians may wish a permanent peace.
Giving up those settlements, however, was opposed by the right-wing faction of his own domestic political coalition. And that is where the tough, stout old general has displayed a Metternich's elegant finesse and delicacy of touch in his diplomacy with Bush and his own Likud Party right wing.
He couldn't consolidate Israeli geography without his right-wing support (which didn't want to give up its dream of an Israel of biblical geography in the West Bank). He couldn't gain that support without President Bush making a series of guarantees and policy pronouncements that would undercut the Israeli right wing's support amongst their own rank file (1. Israel may keep some West Bank settlements; 2. Israel may go militarily back into Gaza to protect itself; 3. Palestinians have no right of return to Israel). And President Bush couldn't make those public statements without frightening the feeble-minded international clucking class that has persisted for a generation in fantasizing a Palestinian leadership willing and able to negotiate a good faith peace.
It was lucky for Sharon that he found in Bush a man who shared his realistic vision of peace and his courage to act. Bush and Sharon are demonstrating an almost Bismarkian diplomacy: shrewd, brutal, realistic, perhaps bloody, but effective. They have definitively rejected the Eleanor Roosevelt/Madeleine Albright/Rodney King/John Kerry/"can't we all just get along" style of diplomacy.
The Palestinians are paying a high price for their revanchist fantasy that Israel can be made to go away, so that they can possess all the land from the Jordan to the Mediterranean. Until this week, the "right of return" to Israel for Palestinians and their descendants who left or were forced out at Israel's birth was still a negotiable item.
Had the Palestinians chosen to participate in real negotiations, doubtlessly the United States would have paid them billions of dollars to waive that fantasy right. Now, unilaterally, that point has been extinguished.
Likewise, Israel's unilateral departure from Gaza (combined with the U.S. guarantee that Israel can defend herself militarily from any danger coming from Gaza) has denied the Palestinians a voice in defining any limitations on those prerogatives of self-defense.
What is the next thing Palestinians will lose out on by their continued inability to negotiate in good faith? They will have no voice in the final line of the fence/wall. Thousands of innocent Palestinians will have their lives and property permanently disrupted as the fence/wall goes up because their leaders won't or can't negotiate in good faith.
It may take two to tango, but as Israel has the dominant military/economic force in the region, it takes only one to draw and enforce border lines.
That will leave Israel reasonably secure from terrorism, but still bordered by an unstable and violent West Bank and Gaza. So, the next price Palestinians will pay for not engaging in good faith negotiations will be to leave a free hand for Sharon and future Israeli governments to manipulate Palestinian rule in their remaining territories.
The recent Israeli acts of aerial executions of Hamas leaders reveals the modern version of the ancient practice of divide et impera divide and rule. Palestinians will be left in a pitiful, ineffective warlordism created by their own failure of governance and compounded by Israeli manipulations to leave them weak and divided.
There is barely time for the better and wiser voices of Palestinian dignity and liberty to make the supreme effort to suppress their terrorism and get to the negotiating table before the old man in a hurry grabs all the remaining chips and leaves the room. Sharon is only doing what he has to do to protect his people. If only a Palestinian leader could give up the fantasy and do the same for his own suffering humanity.
Every weekday JewishWorldReview.com publishes what many in Washington
and in the media consider "must reading." Sign up for the daily JWR update. It's free. Just click here.
Tony Blankley is editorial page editor of The Washington Times. Comment by clicking here.
04/14/04: Islam confronting its demons?
04/08/04: Vigilance is not enough
03/24/04: Kerry personally vulnerable
03/24/04: Futile finger pointing
03/17/04: The Spanish disease
03/10/04: Euro back-stabbers for Kerry
02/25/04: What makes John Kerry tick?
02/18/04: Kerry's pre-emptive war policy
02/11/04: George W. Bush grand strategist?
02/04/04: Elections in the age of terror
01/28/04: There's a war on?
01/21/04: It's good that we live in ignorance of the future
01/14/04: The strange case of immigration politics
01/07/04: Funding for American presidential elections is beginning to go global
12/31/03: Make us laugh
12/24/03: War prophesies
12/17/03: Analyze this!
12/10/03: Until peace is ready to be negotiated …
12/03/03: AFL-CIO meets Monty Python
11/26/03: Republicans need to learn from the Romans
11/19/03: All of a sudden we have a responsible media?
11/12/03: To arms
11/05/03: Mayor Mike's appetite for self-destructive accusations
10/29/03: A bloody march to peace
10/22/03: Calls for a general 's head because his comments may have ruffled the feathers of our esteemed enemies!?
10/08/03: The leakers' agony
10/01/03: Managing a scandal
09/24/03: Will we have to balance our strong ethical and religious revulsion of cloning against the danger of being surpassed by a gene-manipulated super-race?
09/17/03: The skinny on the First Ladies
09/10/03: More than cynicism will be needed to defeat prez
09/03/03: Dead Man Politickin'
08/27/03: Patience is not America's long suit
08/13/03: George Will's trifecta of punitive aspirations
07/30/03: A question for the candidates: Whose side are you on?
07/23/03: When GOPers attack their leader
07/17/03: Spanish fest mirrors U.S. elections
07/09/03: On the horns of a dilemma
06/25/03: The continuing deaths of American and British soldiers in Iraq
should not be rhetorically minimized -- but sanctified
06/18/03: No reason to feel defensive about criticism of the war on terrorism
06/11/03: The Clintons self-proclaimed geniuses have no defense against the charge of cunning mendacity
06/04/03: George 'Machiavelli' Bush? Nah
05/28/03: When 'progressives' become reactionaries
05/21/03: Yes, this conservative is defending the NYTimes
05/14/03: Playing the politics of deflation
05/07/03: Only the stupid could think it'll be the economy: Comparing the Bushes
04/30/03: How to squelch increasing Iraqi distrust of America
04/25/03: Winning the war, losing the peace
04/16/03: Our own domestic Senate Republican Guard better be prepared for a grinding
04/03/03: At this human moment we need to act like humans, not just calculating analysts
04/02/03: If we could only draft Jennings' eyebrow to the cause, we wouldn't need the 4th Armored Division?
03/26/03: This war is showing the world who we really are
03/19/03: Time for America to laugh at itself
03/13/03: They're coming out of the woodwork: Russert, Buchanan and Moran
02/26/03: World history is shifting under our feet --- even our most
experienced statesmen are, effectively, inexperienced
02/19/03: The shame! We've mischaracterized the French
02/12/03: Schroeder and Chirac will be disproportionately undercutting their interests
02/05/03: We need to rise above our temporary anger and seek to preserve our bonds with our European cousins
01/29/03: Who is President Bush's stupidest opponent: Saddam Hussein or Tom Daschle?
01/22/03: We call them our European cousins --- but I demand a DNA test
01/16/03: Dems bare partisan teeth
01/02/03: Before the cheering must come the struggle
12/27/02: Long ago and far away
12/18/02: Be glad that Gore's gone?
12/11/02: What fun! A titanic, once-in-a-century partisan battle royal is in the offing
12/04/02: Kerry atwitter
11/27/02: The unThankful list
11/20/02: First the scare, then the yawn
11/13/02: It's going to be a long two years for Lefty Pelosi and the Frisco Dems
11/06/02: Technology: A pollster's worst enemy --- thank goodness!
10/31/02: Watch this election's Wheel of Fate
10/23/02: The Ari and Colin Show: Politics has never been, well, more vaudeville-like
10/09/02: Bush beats drums of realism
10/02/02: Needed: A political chromatograph to detect any true statements in the public domain
09/25/02: Buchanan's new mag
09/18/02: There are many forms of peace
09/11/02: The imperial period of our history starts
09/04/02: Memo to Powell: In periods of upheaval, the refusal to act gives aid to those bent on destruction
08/30/02: Logging old growth is a sham issue
© 2002, Creators Syndicate