Jewish World Review Nov. 28, 2001 / 13 Kislev, 5762

Jules Witcover

Jules Witcover
JWR's Pundits
World Editorial
Cartoon Showcase

Mallard Fillmore

Michael Barone
Mona Charen
Linda Chavez
Ann Coulter
Greg Crosby
Larry Elder
Don Feder
Suzanne Fields
Paul Greenberg
Bob Greene
Betsy Hart
Nat Hentoff
David Horowitz
Marianne Jennings
Michael Kelly
Mort Kondracke
Ch. Krauthammer
Lawrence Kudlow
Dr. Laura
John Leo
David Limbaugh
Michelle Malkin
Chris Matthews
Michael Medved
MUGGER
Kathleen Parker
Wes Pruden
Sam Schulman
Amity Shlaes
Tony Snow
Thomas Sowell
Cal Thomas
Jonathan S. Tobin
Ben Wattenberg
George Will
Bruce Williams
Walter Williams
Mort Zuckerman

Consumer Reports

More Justice Department folly

http://www.NewsAndOpinion.com -- IF I didn't know better, I'd suspect that the comedy writers for "Saturday Night Live" have taken over at the Justice Department. Except it's not a laughing matter.

Attorney General John Ashcroft's latest explanation for refusing to provide the names of the approximately 1,100 individuals being detained because of possible knowledge about the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks is that he wants to protect their privacy rights. He apparently is much less concerned about their rights to be protected against seizure without specific charges and detention at undisclosed locations.

This latest deep concern against creating what Ashcroft calls "a public blacklist" comes as the FBI under his authority is trying to undertake a dragnet of more than 5,000 people, mostly men 18 to 33 of Middle Eastern background, who may or may not know something about the terrorism threat.

The U.S. Attorney's office in Detroit is sending out letters in the area, which has an Arab-American and Arab immigrant community of as many as 300,000 souls, asking recipients to come in voluntarily to be interviewed.

"Your name was brought to our attention," the letter says, "because among other things you came to Michigan on a visa from a country where there are groups that support, advocate or finance international terrorism." The letter goes on: "We have no reason to believe that you are in any way associated with terrorist activities. Nevertheless, you may know something that could be helpful in our efforts."

The letter has already sent shock waves through the Arab-American community, with some recipients wondering why they have been singled out and even raising fears that they are being rounded up for similar detention, in the way Japanese-Americans were herded into concentration camps in World War II.

While the Detroit authorities have given assurances that those who do come in voluntarily "will be treated with respect and courtesy throughout the interview process," many immigrants quake at any contact from the feds. It's easy to say they have nothing to fear when they know Ashcroft has said he intends to tighten up on possible visa violators on any grounds he can find.

Just why the Justice Department thinks anybody who has significant knowledge of terrorists or their activities is likely to stroll in voluntarily and sing seems more than a bit na´ve. But then, when Ashcroft recently authorized eavesdropping on conversations between detainees and their lawyers, it was specified that they would be notified in advance that federal agents would be listening in. How's that as an invitation to dummy up?

The letters respectfully asking their recipients to call in for an interview appointment may remind the more suspicious of them of police sting operations in Washington and other cities not too long ago. Individuals wanted by the law on various charges were sent fancy and elaborate invitations to parties to meet local sports celebrities. When they showed up, often dressed to the nines, the doors were locked behind them by the cops and they were shipped off to the slammer.

There's no reason to think any such thing will happen in this matter. But Ashcroft's insensitivity to civil liberties in his zeal to do his part in the war on terrorism on the home front understandably is casting him in many eyes as a chief law-enforcement officer guided by the argument that the ends justify the means.

His boss, President Bush, has contributed to the concerns of civil libertarians with his declaration that military tribunals may supplant civil courts in trying suspected terrorists. And not only civil libertarians are worried; the government of Spain says it won't extradite eight suspected terrorists to this country as long as they face military trials and the death penalty here.

The rationale that the nation is at war has led to too many regrettable excesses in the past. Bush has also said care must be taken in fighting the war that the terrorists don't succeed in destroying cherished American values and liberties. It's something he needs to remember himself, and remind his attorney general, too.


Comment on JWR contributor Jules Witcover's column by clicking here.

11/26/01:Ashcroft still under fire
11/21/01: Normalcy vs. security at the White House
11/12/01: Bush's latest pep talk
11/07/01: The blame game on airport security
11/05/01: Bellwether gubernatorial elections?
11/02/01: Feingold's complaint
10/31/01: Putting the cart before the horse?
10/29/01: Show business on economic stimulus
10/26/01: No political business as usual
10/24/01: Senatorial bravado
10/22/01: Split decision on gun rights
10/16/01: New York mayor's race: What kind of experience?
10/15/01: New York: Making a comeback
10/11/01: Giuliani: Fly in the election ointment
10/08/01: One or two New Yorks?
10/05/01: Providing your own security
10/01/01: Getting back to 'normal'
09/28/01: Muzzling the Voice Of America
09/26/01: Bush's transformation
09/24/01: Using a tragedy for a federal bailout
09/21/01: A view of tragedy at home from abroad
09/14/01: Script for AlGore's coming-out party
08/31/01: Scandal and privacy in politics
08/24/01: On replacing Helms
08/22/01: Politics takes a summer holiday
08/15/01: The resurfacing of AlGore
08/13/01: You can go home again
08/10/01: Governors' Conference drought
08/08/01: Governors defend their turf
08/06/01: New Bush muscle with congress
08/03/01: America's benign neglect
07/30/01: Where is the fear factor?
07/26/01: Dubya, Nancy Reagan and the Pope
07/23/01: Bush's congressional dilemma
07/19/01: Katharine Graham, giant
07/11/01: Finessing election reform
07/09/01: Listening to, and watching, Ashcroft
07/06/01: New comedian in the House (of Representatives)
06/27/01: Spinning Campaign Finance Reform's latest 'headway'
06/25/01: When Dubya says 'the check is in the mail,' you can believe him
06/22/01: The push on patients' rights
06/20/01: If you can't trust historians, how can you trust history?
06/18/01: World Refugee Day
06/13/01: Remembering 'Hubert'
06/11/01: Ventura faces government shutdown
06/06/01: McCain doth protest too much
06/04/01: Memo to the Bush daughters
05/30/01: Missing in action: Democratic outrage
05/30/01: Honoring World War II vets
05/23/01: Lauding the Nixon pardon
05/21/01: Messin' with McCain
05/18/01: A great movie plot
05/16/01: The level of public sensibility these days
05/14/01: "I am Al Gore. I used to be the next president of the United States"

© 2001, TMS