Jewish World Review Feb. 20, 2003 / 18 Adar I, 5763
Anti-war group gets it right about great humanitarian tragedy in last Gulf War
A United Nations task force charged with coordinating the response of the
UN's humanitarian agencies fears that up to 500,000 Iraqis could be killed
or wounded, and fully ten million of Iraq's 26 million people put at risk if
there is a second Gulf War.
The UN planners assume war would halt Iraq's oil production, severely
degrade its electric power grid, and disrupt the ability of the Iraqi
government to distribute food rations. They assume also there will be an
outbreak of diseases "of pandemic proportions," due chiefly to contamination
of water supplies. They estimate roughly two million Iraqis will become
The report was secret, by an antiwar group got a copy of it and posted it on
a web site.
The report assumes fighting would be protracted, and that about 100,000
Iraqis would be killed or injured as a direct result of combat, with another
400,000 suffering as a result of disruption of services.
Estimating casualties in a war that hasn't happened yet is very difficult to
do. As we shall see, estimating casualties in a war that has just ended
isn't easy. The UN's track record of prognostication is poor. Some officials
of UN humanitarian agencies predicted there would tens of thousands of
civilian casualties in the Afghan war. A survey conducted by the Associated
Press last year found fewer than 600.
Casualty estimates from the Gulf War are, a dozen years later, still a
political football. General Norman Schwarzkopf, got the misinformation ball
rolling by fatuously estimating, at a press conference at war's end, that as
many as 100,000 Iraqi soldiers had been killed in the fighting.
Heaven only knows where "Stormin' Norman" was getting his numbers. The current
consensus estimate of military analysts is that between 20,000 and 25,000
Iraqi soldiers, and between 1,000 and 3,000 Iraqi civilians were killed in
the fighting. But two who have done some of the most detailed analytical
work - former Defense Intelligence Agency analyst John Heidenrich, and Dr.
John Mueller, a political science professor at Ohio State University, think
the numbers were much lower.
Basing his calculations on the number of Iraqi bodies actually found (577),
and the normal crew strength of the vehicles we destroyed, Heidenrich
estimated the number of Iraqis killed at between 1,500 and 6,000, with the
lower number being the more likely. The number of civilian deaths from
bombing was less than 1,000, Heidenrich said. Mueller, working
independently, came to a similar conclusion.
Leftists have made vastly greater claims for the numbers of civilian deaths,
but have been undermined by other leftists who inadvertently commit truth:
"Recently I spent four days in Baghdad with a small group of longtime peace
activists who'd gone there to document civilian damage caused by U.S.
bombing," wrote Erika Munk in the Nation in May, 1991. "We expected to find
enormous unreported destruction...Instead, we found a city whose homes and
offices were almost entirely intact, where the electricity was coming back
and the water was running."
The highest estimate of Iraqi casualties in the Gulf War taken seriously by
scholars was from Carnegie Mellon University professor Beth Daponte, then a
researcher at the Commerce Department. She estimated in January, 1992, that
approximately 205,000 Iraqis died as a result of Desert Storm, the domestic
rebellions that followed, and from deprivation and disease.
Daponte's figures are cited often by those who wish to blame Iraqi deaths on
the United States. But a large element in them - which Daponte estimated at
35,000 - were the Iraqis killed by Saddam in his repression of the Kurdish
and Shia risings. Others have estimated that death toll at 80,000 to
Columbia University public health specialist Richard Garfield estimated last
year that 350,000 Iraqi children under five had died since the Gulf War,
chiefly as a result of privations caused by UN sanctions. Sanctions haven't
served to restrain Saddam Hussein, and they have caused misery for tens of
thousands of innocent people.
Though I doubt this was their intent, Daponte's research, and Garfield's
indicate the great humanitarian tragedy was not the Gulf War, but the
failure to remove Saddam Hussein after it. The suffering of the Iraqi people
will not end until he is gone.
Enjoy this writer's work? Why not sign-up for the daily JWR update. It's free. Just click here.
Comment on JWR contributor Jack Kelly's column by clicking here.
02/18/03: Iraqis: Why are these people marching for tyranny?
02/07/03: French kiss(ed)-off
02/05/03: Does the FBI have the ability to protect us from terrorists already here?
02/03/03: The "Axis of Weasels"
01/29/03: A bit of the jitters
01/27/03: The world's mediocre intelligence agency
01/21/03: By reaffirming GOP opposition to racism, president demonstrates willingness to confront liars
01/16/03: Why the United States should withdraw all of its military forces from South Korea as rapidly as we reasonably can
01/14/03: Federal incompetence driven by political correctness, not trampling of civil liberties, is what we should fear
01/09/03: Bag this boondoggle: The V-22 Osprey would hurt our national defense
01/07/03: Another Korean war?
12/26/02: Learning from Canada's economic suicide
12/24/02: A moral dilemma: Support a vicious fascist dictator or the poor and downtrodden?
12/20/02: Time to tell the truth: The great movement of blacks to the Democratic Party took place for economic reasons, not because of civil rights
12/18/02: Nothing better illustrates Trent Lott's unfitness for the post of Senate
Majority Leader than his desperate efforts to cling to it
12/16/02: Debunker mentality: It's hard work not seeing ties between Iraq and al-Qaida
12/12/02: GOP ideologues turning on Lott --- better sacrifice the leader than the party
12/06/02: Curing our democracy of afflictions
12/02/02: Conscription, like the horse cavalry, is an artifact of a bygone time
11/27/02: What Saddam faces
11/25/02: Why war with Iraq can be averted
11/19/02: A draft would harm the military
11/12/02: The 2002 elections and Nixon
11/07/02: Democratic overreaction to our recent "cosmically important" election
10/30/02: Show North Korea we're serious: Polish off Saddam
10/22/02: The squealing in the Pentagon is a proof of Rummy's effectiveness
10/16/02: The tactical challenge we face
10/10/02: Silence more despicable than seditious noise
10/08/02: Bu$h and the bu$ine$$ of war
10/01/02: Gore's calculated risk may well get him the Dems' nomination
09/25/02: Schroeder may find the fruits of victory sour
09/25/02: Making Saddam change his spots
09/19/02: Bush's resolve already has paid dividends
09/17/02: Courageous Iranians
09/13/02: If you never served in the military, you have no right to an opinion
09/10/02: Why the 'air marshals' will fail
09/05/02: Resurrecting the "Happy Darky"
08/31/02: Are Bush's inactions against Iraq calculated?
08/23/02: Dems can't take the minority vote for granted any longer
08/20/02: No proof of Saddam's wrongdoing? Yeah, right
08/15/02: Mineta's war on what?
08/13/02: When Gore said he wanted to be his 'own man,' what was he thinking!?
08/08/02: Picking a tree for Cheney's hanging
08/06/02: Fears about the Department of Homeland Security are misplaced
08/01/02: The greatest strategic deception since Eisenhower convinced Hitler the Allies were going to land at the Pas de Calais?
07/30/02: State Dept.'s anti-American actions
07/26/02: Journalists are making sure Americans can't differentiate between the stock market and the economy
07/23/02: Iran's is on the verge of a social and political explosion. So why is media ignoring it?
07/17/02: FBI isn't supposed to stand for Foolish, Blind and Incompetent
07/12/02: The ICC tramples on rights Americans take for granted
07/09/02: Was LA International Airport shooting, in fact, good news?
07/02/02: What the "intelligence community" can learn from Alexander the Great
06/28/02: Muslim link in Oklahoma City bombing revisited
06/25/02: A good environmental scare needs two ingredients - an impending catastrophe, and someone to blame for it
06/21/02: Stirring the security pot
06/18/02: Why the military is so messed up
06/14/02: Vast majority $68.7 billion proposed for weapons will be spent on systems of little use in the war on terror
06/12/02: Bush saw them and raised them, and he's holding the aces
06/10/02: Some heads need to roll
06/04/02: A new draft for the 'war on terror'?
05/31/02: So the FBI has finally caught up to our priorities?
05/29/02: Taking on common sense
05/23/02: Political terrorists
05/21/02: There is a great deal to fret about, but I've never been more optimistic
05/15/02: If there is a way for America to lose the war, Gen. Tommy Franks can find it
05/13/02: Impartial justice against Americans by the UN?
05/07/02: Want to win the 'war on terror'? Reinstate the draft
05/03/02: An expanded NATO is needed as a counterweight to the UN and the EU
04/29/02: Islamic 'smarts'
04/26/02: Did Bush play his Aces with Abdullah wisely?
04/23/02: Why peace in the Mideast is closer than ever
04/19/02: What the Arabs of Gaza and the West Bank gained from the "peace accords"
04/17/02: Logical Muslim allies
04/10/02: How to guarantee an infinite Mideast war
04/08/02: Saddam's American friends
04/05/02: Arab winners and sinners
04/01/02: Why is the commander of U.S. Central Command not coming clean to the American people?
03/31/02: Dubya under attack … by conservatives
03/26/02: Saddam watch coming to an end?
03/21/02: Get the Jews!
03/19/02: It's time pols and gov bureaucrats be held to the same
standard of accountability we insist for corporate execs
03/15/02: Khaki Throat
03/12/02: Making foreign cheaters pay
03/08/02: Timidity and indecision by senior American commanders
03/04/02: Why 9-11? Ex-CIA officials come clean
02/25/02: Don't rule out a quick victory --- even if prez says otherwise
02/21/02: Saving our military from itself
02/19/02: Front Page fiction
02/15/02: Our European allies are like the fat kid who wants to play quarterback
02/13/02: Is the Army in danger of becoming "irrelevant"?
02/11/02: So, I "propagate hatred" …
02/06/02: Bush whacking the media
02/04/02: Why serious folks disregard the European Union --- and why Bush must, too
01/30/02: Give economy pneumonia in order to protect it from a cold
01/28/02: Media is its own worst enemy
01/25/02: Journalists making road to peace a bumpy ride, or: A case study in stupidity
01/23/02: Toward a stronger defense at a lower cost
01/21/02: How Bush could be Generations X and Y's Kennedy ... and guarantee a GOP victory in the midterm elections
© 2002, Jack Kelly