Clicking on banner ads enables JWR to constantly improve
Jewish World Review July 11, 2000 / 8 Tamuz, 5760

Betsy Hart

Betsy Hart
JWR's Pundits
World Editorial
Cartoon Showcase

Mallard Fillmore

Michael Barone
Mona Charen
Linda Chavez
Ann Coulter
Greg Crosby
Larry Elder
Don Feder
Suzanne Fields
James Glassman
Paul Greenberg
Bob Greene
Nat Hentoff
David Horowitz
Marianne Jennings
Michael Kelly
Mort Kondracke
Ch. Krauthammer
Lawrence Kudlow
Dr. Laura
John Leo
David Limbaugh
Michelle Malkin
Jackie Mason
Michael Medved
Kathleen Parker
Wes Pruden
Debbie Schlussel
Sam Schulman
Amity Shlaes
Roger Simon
Tony Snow
Thomas Sowell
Cal Thomas
Jonathan S. Tobin
Ben Wattenberg
George Will
Bruce Williams
Walter Williams
Mort Zuckerman

Consumer Reports

Limiting a child's choices -- MY DAUGHTER recently celebrated her fourth birthday, and hosting it "off-campus" meant I ended up taking five little ones to a busy children's theme restaurant. When the waiter arrived - looking rather nervous, I thought - to begin querying each child about her lunch preference, I simply informed him, without consulting the kids myself, that my charges would each have a grilled cheese sandwich and a Sprite. (Note for the record: my kids rarely get sodas instead of milk.)

Anyway, the waiter was stunned and thankful - and I guess it's obvious why. Today giving children choices in every conceivable matter - often, it seems for little more than the sake of giving them choices - seems to be the Holy Grail of child-rearing. So for me to assert my parental prerogative and make choices for these children was, apparently, totally unexpected.

Being a mom of three little ones I see it all the time with even the youngest kids. "Sweetie, please pick something - doesn't a hot dog look good? No? How about a hamburger? " "It's your choice, but if you don't learn to swim in class now, you won't be able to visit Susie's pool this summer." "Honey, I'll let you decide, but if you have a nap you'll feel much better for tonight's party." And my all time favorite, "Well you can keep fussing if you like - it's your choice - but if you don't stop I'm going to leave without you" /"not bring you back"/fill-in-the blank.

Sure it's appropriate and necessary as children mature to let them take on more responsibility, including making certain choices for themselves within the purview of their parents' authority. (When allowing a choice is called for, limiting it to one of two things is wise.) But today's culture seems to say that even the youngest children should be given choices primarily so they can be personally empowered - not so that they can learn to make good, sound, decisions considering the whole context for themselves and others. And what a world of difference there is between the two.

A very wise woman and mom I know once said to me "children do not learn to make good choices by making choices. They learn to make good choices by having good choices made for them." In other words, it's after watching wise decisions be made on their behalf, and when appropriate having those decisions explained - not justified - that children are best equipped to navigate that process themselves.

That means, it seems to me, kids should be allowed to make choices only within the safe context of parental authority and only when (but by no means always when) they have gained the breadth of knowledge they need to intelligently make the choice at hand. And just as important, when they can rightly see the consequences of that choice for others, not just themselves. So consider something as simple as ordering in a restaurant. Maybe choosing a hot dog instead of a grilled cheese is a fine decision for a certain age child and one she can be allowed to make - but not if she's one of a group of children who, all ruminating about their choices, would unnecessarily inconvenience a busy waiter.

Nor can children possibly understand their own physical and moral needs well-enough to make choices that impact those areas, though I see them allowed to do so all the time. Even to the point where they are allowed to "choose" whether or not to obey their parents.

But perhaps the biggest problem with constantly offering a child what seem like even innocuous choices may be the one so clearly yet unwittingly portrayed on a television program I saw on child-rearing. A toddler was chronicled terrorizing his parents about the issue of bedtime. The "expert" counselor called on to dispense his wisdom told the distraught parents it was important to give the little guy choices throughout the day, but that as bedtime approached they should begin to limit his decision-making so he wouldn't think he could make choices about important things like bedtime, too.

But of course a child who is given even benign choices all day long will rebel when that prerogative is suddenly reined in. Duh.

Such parents should beware. They are only training their child to exercise his selfish whims, instead of training him over time to make wise decisions considering the entire context for both himself and others, and within his parents' authority.

And if they feel challenged now - just wait until he is teenager.

JWR contributor Betsy Hart, a frequent commentator on CNN and the Fox News Channel, can be reached by clicking here.


07/06/00: Accounting for your health
06/21/00: It's a bad time to be a boy in America
06/13/00: The state of our unions
06/02/00: Federalizing care of kids
05/17/00: The natural food threat
05/09/00: To stop gun violence, keep families intact
05/03/00: Pass the fat, please
04/25/00: Something just for boys
04/18/00: When toleration goes too far
04/10/00: Women warriors
04/05/00: Confessions of a soccer mom
03/30/00: Getting an education about schools
03/22/00: If you're a parent, act like one!
03/14/00: Not child advocates, but self-advocates
03/06/00: McCain not what he seemed at first
02/29/00: An effective answer to social problems
02/22/00: The feminists' newest target: Toys
02/06/00: Harassing the harassers
01/31/00: It doesn't take a village to raise a child --- it takes a scheduler
01/25/00: Psuedo science and global warming
01/18/00: Socially responsible nonsense
01/10/00: Monica may be onto something
12/27/99: Sometimes it matters quite a lot what government thinks
12/17/99: Teens have no inherent 'right to privacy'
12/10/99: Buying a minivan and tossing the SUV
12/03/99: On the mommy track
11/05/99:The waste of recycling
11/01/99: Welcome to Harvard pre-school
10/22/99: No disaster for women that Dole is out
10/19/99: 'Humanitarian' hypocrites
10/15/99: On a first-name basis with a three-year-old

© 2000, Scripps Howard News Service