Jewish World Review August 27, 1999 /15 Elul, 5759
Such is the deplorable state of today's broadcast journalism that Clinton co-defender, redeemer and friend, George Stephanopoulos, can go directly to ABC News as a commentator/analyst and then be morphed into a broadcast journalist while his old boss is still in office. Most former members of the revolving-door club between government and journalism at least put a little space between partisan political activity and the profession. There's a law keeping former government officials from lobbying their old associates for one year. No such law exists in journalism, but maybe there should be one.
Stephanopoulos is a nice fellow. It's not his fault. ABC News President David Westin violates whatever remnant of real journalism remains by announcing that he's grooming Stephanopoulos for a reporter position. "We're all conscious of the sensitivity with him having been a part of the news in Washington,'' explains Westin. If he is that conscious, why doesn't he hire a former member of the Bush or Reagan administrations to balance things out? This would be just as bad, but at least the public might credit him for fairness.
Westin says he wouldn't want Stephanopoulos to be the beat reporter for the Gore campaign. Does this mean he'd consider him as a beat reporter for the campaign of George W. Bush or one of the other Republican candidates? Does Westin think there might be a public perception of bias if Stephanopoulos covered a Democratic contender but not a Republican?
Westin lauds Stephanopoulos' "increasing strength and maturity.'' Funny, I never felt the need to put "increasing strength and maturity'' on my resume when applying for a job. And then Westin adds, "There has been a history of people not growing up in journalism becoming journalists,'' as if this is something to be encouraged.
In his book, "How the News Makes Us Dumb,'' University of Florida history professor C. John Sommerville writes that the way broadcast news is misproduced today is actually good because it is driving people away and allowing them to develop alternative means of receiving information that will be far more beneficial to them. Sommerville contends that the idea of daily news creates an information industry that must constantly be satisfied with "news,'' no matter how irrelevant or unimportant: "We are now seeing what happens when one depends entirely on daily reports, with their decontextualizing and deconstructing tendencies .... For news has no sense of scale. It concentrates the mind when we thought (its purpose) was to broaden the mind.''
If journalism plucks people out of the White House, or anywhere else, without testing their reporting skills in local stations or newspapers before giving them a national platform, then journalism itself is further diminished in the minds of an already skeptical public which regards the profession with proper distrust and disgust.
The transformation of George Stephanopoulos from Clinton campaign operative, to Clinton White House operative and apologist, to network commentator, to reporter, along with the industry's failure to fulfill its obligation to fully investigate and expose the illegal and immoral activities of this president and his co-conspirators, is more evidence of dysfunctional broadcast news that is beyond repair.
There is a difference between being informed and being wise, argues Sommerville. George
Stephanopoulos will be another informer. What he says will not make us any wiser. It's a
dumb move from a crumbling profession that has contributed to the dumbing down of the