Clicking on banner ads keeps JWR alive
Jewish World Review May 4, 1999 /18 Iyar 5759

Cal Thomas

Cal Thomas
JWR's Pundits
World Editorial
Cartoon Showcase

Tony Snow
Dr. Laura
Michael Kelly
Paul Greenberg
David Corn
Sam Schulman
Philip Weiss
Mort Zuckerman
Richard Chesnoff
Larry Elder
Cal Thomas
Jonathan S. Tobin
Don Feder
Linda Chavez
Mona Charen
Thomas Sowell
Walter Williams
Ben Wattenberg


Jeb Bush chooses to save kids, not institutions

(JWR) ---- (
ON HEARING THAT THE FLORIDA LEGISLATURE had passed and Gov. Jeb Bush intended to sign the nation's first statewide school choice law, the president of Florida chapters of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People, Leon Russell, said: "We won't allow this to become law. We believe these opportunity scholarships -- aka vouchers -- dismantle public education.''

The public education system as we have known it for a century has dismantled itself. More than old buildings are falling down. So is the quality of education. It is especially bad for minority children whose interests Russell is supposed to be advancing. Minority parents favor school choice by a wide margin. It's time to shake up the system by ending the monopoly. We should be more concerned about what the children are getting than benefits flowing toward the teachers unions and the rest of the education establishment.

The usual suspects will fight this in court, but they are swimming against a strong tide.

It is unfair and immoral to force people to keep their children mired in public schools that fail to teach them the basic educational and moral skills they need to make a decent living and a satisfying life. The National Education Association, which regularly passes pro-choice resolutions on abortion, vehemently opposes choice on education for those fortunate enough to have been born. Why is choice sacrosanct when it comes to life and death, but unacceptable when it comes to education? It's because to allow parents to choose would erode the political power now enjoyed by the NEA and the rest of the education establishment that has put itself ahead of the best interests of parents and children in a shameless pursuit of self-preservation, not child education.

Under the Bush plan, Florida schools will be graded. If any school gets an "F'' two straight years, students will be offered vouchers worth $4,000 that they can use at the private, religious or other public school of their choice.

The Supreme Court has indicated it is not hostile to the school-choice concept. Last year, it voted 8-1 to reject a challenge to Milwaukee's school-choice program. Thirty-four states and Washington, D.C., have passed charter school legislation.

In the most exciting development of all, entrepreneurs Ted Forstmann and John Walton have begun a nationwide scholarship program designed to free inner-city minority youth from dead-end public schools. Forty cities are involved, with more sure to come. The response has been tremendous, quieting some politicians who have claimed that the poor don't want vouchers or scholarships.

Early studies indicate positive achievement when students and parents get to choose. A study of New York's School Choice Scholarship Foundation by Harvard University and Mathematica Policy Research, Inc., found that 4th- and 5th-grade students in the program scored 4 percentile points higher than a control group in reading and 6 points higher in math.

A Phi Delta Kappa/Gallup Poll last year found 56 percent of parents with children in public schools support school choice. The numbers are higher in many minority communities, such as the nation's capital, where a Washington Post survey discovered that 65 percent of African-Americans with incomes under $50,000 favor using federal dollars to send children to private or religious schools.

New York pastor and former Democratic Congressman Floyd Flake has said:"I'm not against public schools. I am against public schools where educational mediocrity goes unchallenged.'' That's the point.

Gov. Jeb Bush is opening previously locked doors to opportunity and hope. If the new law survives court challenges, there will be no stopping school choice. Children will initially benefit, but in the long run so will teachers and administrators because the system will be competitive and will foster improvement. If it doesn't, such schools, like any business, would be forced to close. Either way, children, parents and the nation win. Only the political power brokers lose. And that's not bad, either.


04/26/99: Surrendering our civilization
04/26/99: War abroad, war at home
04/22/99: Those wild and crazy (Democrat) tax-cutters
04/16/99: Bubba’s contemptible behavior
04/14/99:Elizabeth Dole's choice
04/09/99: The taxman cometh
03/30/99: Human-rights terror in China
03/25/99: Yasser Arafat:
bad cop, worse cop
03/23/99: Bubba’s multiplied lies
03/18/99: Reinventing AlGore
03/16/99:Americans get bull while China shops
03/12/99: Bill Lan Lee: Flouting the law
03/09/99: Don't worry about your child, be happy
03/08/99:The ‘lady' is a tramp
03/04/99: Proving myself to President Clinton
02/24/99: New slaves to a new slavery
02/22/99: Character-plus
02/19/99: GOP losers tell winner how to win
02/17/99: The Clinton legacy
02/10/99: More a man, less a president

©1999, LA TimesSyndicate