It would make a perfect clickbait ad "Learn this one simple trick to stop worrying about
What's the trick? All you have to do is take Trump seriously, but not literally.
The formulation is credited to reporter
Even the president-elect's team has declared this a kind of
"This is the problem with the media,"
Trump has hinted that he buys this heuristic as well. Last week, he explained that he never really meant it when he said in April "we're not going to let Carrier leave."
"I said, 'Carrier will never leave,'" he admitted. "But that was a euphemism. I was talking about Carrier like all other companies from here on in."
As a defense of some of candidate Trump's statements, this distinction is not bad, and as an indictment of the media, it's pretty good. The press treated Trump as a joke, not appreciating the fact that for many voters the media's scorn is a badge of honor.
Of course, Trump isn't the only politician to expect "non-literal" status. Vice President
The non-literal approach to Biden is safe for two reasons. Because he is a well-known character in the
Trump is different. On his own terms he's an outsider and a "disrupter" who claims that political elites range from stupid to malevolent. He also has zero experience in foreign or domestic policy. What he says -- and how he says it -- takes on greater importance precisely because he lacks a track record in public office to put his language in context.
This seriously-not-literally thing is a great analytical insight into how then-candidate Trump communicated with his supporters. But it is fairly ridiculous hogwash as a prescription for how to treat an actual president, or president-elect, of
When Trump says millions of people voted illegally, how should the news media go about taking that indefensible claim "seriously but not literally"? Should reporters assume that some number of people voted illegally, but not millions? Or that millions of people voted, but not illegally?
When Trump says he spoke on the telephone with the president of
Perhaps we shouldn't take the literally-seriously distinction too literally. Perhaps what Trump supporters really mean is that he should get a free pass whenever his mouth gets him in trouble?
Trump has said, "I know words, I have the best words." He's also said he could be more presidential than anybody, except maybe
What a president says matters. And credibility -- with citizens, allies, enemies and markets -- is a finite resource, easily depleted when you think you'll never be held to account for what you blurt out.