July 8th, 2020


Who's to blame for Planned Parenthood murders?

Ramesh Ponnuru

By Ramesh Ponnuru Bloomberg View

Published Dec. 2, 2015

. Jim Pouillon was murdered in 2009 by a man who objected to the anti-abortion pamphlet he was distributing. Press coverage was scant, but some pro-choice groups, to their credit, denounced the murder. The New York Times didn't run articles suggesting that over-the-top pro-abortion rights rhetoric -- likening anti-abortion supporters to the Taliban, accusing them of seeking to oppress women, urging a crackdown on their ability to protest abortion -- had set the stage for the murder.

Anti-abortion supporters refrained from suggesting that pro-abortion rights groups bore responsibility for the murder. (I'm not aware of any exceptions to this generalization.) That was to their credit: The suggestion would have been obscene.

Pro-abortion rights supporters have been less restrained in the wake of the recent murder of three people at a Planned Parenthood clinic in Colorado. They intend to turn the killings "into a political moment they say will put abortion opponents on the defensive." The Washington Post, which didn't cover Pouillon's murder, is reporting sympathetically on claims that the rhetoric of mainstream anti-abortion supporters is to blame for the killings. Reporters are challenging anti-abortion politicians about the murders, which also didn't happen in the Pouillon case. The governor of Colorado says that "inflammatory rhetoric" from anti-abortion supporters played a role.

Why might these cases have inspired such different reactions? It can't be that anti-abortion violence is a frequent occurrence, and thus fits into a larger story: It is only slightly more common than pro-abortion rights violence against adults, which is to say not very common at all.

I suspect the media is crediting the pro-abortion-rights spin on these killings because most journalists are themselves on this side and inclined to see anti-abortion supporters as extremists. And so reporters who would consider it unfair to blame cop-killings on the rhetoric of some Black Lives Matter activists don't have the same sympathetic reflex when anti-abortion supporters are in the dock.

Anti-abortion supporters have decried the killings in Colorado, and complained that they're being smeared. But it must be admitted that political rhetoric -- all political activism, for that matter -- can inspire violence. Many on this side say that abortion is an evil on par with slavery. And some deranged people may try to play the part of John Brown in that analogy. Thankfully, such people are exceedingly rare.

When violence is committed in the name of a political movement, its responsible members have a duty to condemn it and to seek to root it out of their ranks -- two things that anti-abortion supporters have done. Do members of a movement have a duty to restrain their words for fear that madmen will commit outrages based on them? I think the answer is that political activists should refrain from saying anything more inflammatory than needed to make their case against the injustice that moves them -- not so much from fear of the deranged as from love of their fellow citizens. The reason Hillary Clinton should stop saying that peaceful, run-of-the-mill anti-abortion supporters are like terrorists is not that she's likely to inspire violence; it's that saying it makes our political debates even nastier and dumber than they already are.

Anti-abortion rhetoric isn't the real issue for pro-abortion rights supporters anyway. The bedrock anti-abortion view -- which, if you haven't figured it out already, I share -- is that abortion is the unjust killing of living human beings. Any expression of that view, any political action taken to advance it, is going to offend many who favor abortion rights, and could lead some people to violent acts. Abortion rights supporters who want anti-abortion supporters to stop saying that abortion kills unborn children aren't objecting to the anti-abortion movement's rhetoric; they're objecting to its existence.

And they're trying to score political points by associating the vast majority of anti-abortion supporters with a tiny violent fringe. What should, but will not, give them pause is the example of the man who died trying to defend the victims in Colorado. Few people are as courageous as Officer Garrett Swasey. But if you want an example of anti-abortion principles in action during this crime, look at him and not his killer.


11/19/15: Obama's Education Department not iberal enough
11/04/15: Should Republicans care about income inequality?
10/26/15: Jeb Bush: More Conservative Than You Think
10/16/15: In command: Why Hillary is on track to win her party's nomination
10/14/15: Bush offers a real health-care replacement
09/25/15: 4 lessons of Scott Walker's campaign collapse
09/21/15: What happens if the new Trump is just boring?
08/31/15: One health care question Republicans must answer
08/24/15: Why Trump's immigration proposals are resonating
08/17/15: Jeb Bush's recipe for economic disappointment
07/31/15: The Dems are blessed to have Hillary
07/15/15: Anxiety over education may shape the 2016 campaign
06/25/15: Obamacare will survive Supreme Court challenge
06/17/15: 6 things Jeb Bush revealed about his candidacy
06/11/15: Yes, Rubio made bad financial choices
06/03/15: Why replacing Obamacare is dividing Republicans
05/26/15: Sixteen questions Hillary Clinton should answer
05/14/15: Free-trade opponents get less logical by the day
02/25/15: Republicans unite to ignore immigration in 2016
02/11/15: 6 questions as Scott Walker eyes 2016 campaign
02/09/15: Bobby Jindal shows how not to replace Obamacare
02/02/15: Republicans should plan for post-Obamacare world
01/29/15: Why Obamacare should lose in next Supreme Court case
01/22/15: Proving they can work with Dems isn't GOP's most important political task
01/13/15: Newly empowered Congress passing tax reform in 2015? Not a chance, and here's why

Comment by clicking here.

Ramesh Ponnuru has covered national politics and public policy for 18 years. He is an author and Bloomberg View columnist.