Republican candidates ahead of their second debate are flummoxed about how to deal with the perpetual insult machine that is Donald Trump: Most ignore him in hopes he will go away, while a few lash out at him. Yet he keeps rising in the polls.
Of course he does because his opponents are following the wrong script. They treat him as if he were a conventional candidate, and not the schoolyard bully he has been acting like. There is nothing to be found in the Lee Atwater or Karl Rove playbook to handle Trump. His competitors would do better going to StopBullying.gov, the Web site for a public-service campaign run by the Department of Health and Human Services.
Substitute "candidate" or "candidates" for each mention of "child," "children" or "kids" on StopBullying.gov, and you quickly see how Trump has been mishandled:
"Bullying is unwanted, aggressive behavior among candidates that involves a real or perceived power imbalance. The behavior is repeated, or has the potential to be repeated, over time. Bullying includes actions such as making threats, spreading rumors, attacking someone physically or verbally, and excluding someone from a group on purpose."
Threats? "I've been very nice to you, although I could probably maybe not be based on the way you have treated me," Trump said at the first debate to Fox News's Megyn Kelly, who has reportedly received death threats from Trump supporters.
Rumors? "I really don't know," Trump said when asked recently if President Obama was born in the United States. Trump, who led the "birther" movement questioning Obama's birth certificate, has also been peddling stories about the Mexican government sending rapists into America.
Verbal attacks? "Look at that face! Would anyone vote for that? Can you imagine that, the face of our next president?!" Trump said of Carly Fiorina, the only woman in the Republican presidential contest.
Exclusion? Here's what he tweeted about Bobby Jindal after his rival tried to stand up to Trump's bullying: "Bobby Jindal did not make the debate stage and therefore I have never met him. . . . I only respond to people that register more than 1 percent in the polls."
StopBullying.gov specifically tells bully spotters to look for name-calling
("Stupid!" "Fool!" "Loser!" "Clown!"), inappropriate sexual comments ("blood coming out of her wherever"), taunting (Trump called rival Lindsey Graham an "idiot" before giving out the senator's cellphone number to a crowd) and cyberbullying (twitter.com/realDonaldTrump).
StopBullying.gov helps us understand why the initial strategy of Jeb Bush and others to ignore Trump's taunts was a failure: "Not saying anything could make it worse for everyone. The candidate who is bullying will think it is ok to keep treating others that way." It also explains the folly in the strategy of those such as Jindal who answer Trump's abuse in kind the political equivalent of punching the bully in the face: "Remind candidates to only intervene if it feels safe to do so," because fighting back "could get the candidate hurt."
We also see how Ted Cruz has enabled Trump as one of the "candidates who assist" "these candidates may encourage the bullying behavior and occasionally join in." And we see what's wrong with the responses by Fox News boss Roger Ailes, who has alternately scolded Trump and made peace with him, and Republican National Committee boss Reince Priebus, who went to Trump on bended knee to get him to pledge loyalty to the GOP: "When adults respond quickly and consistently to bullying behavior they send the message that it is not acceptable."
StopBullying.gov has some wisdom for CNN's Jake Tapper, the moderator of Wednesday's debate, when he (inevitably) encounters Trump's bullying. "Intervene immediately. It is ok to get another adult to help. . . . Don't think candidates can work it out without adult help."
And the targets of Trump's bullying? "Look at the candidate bullying you and tell him or her to stop in a calm, clear voice. You can also try to laugh it off."
Bystanders and other adults in this case, let's apply the term loosely to supporters, party officials and journalists have a role, too: Because "those who bully are encouraged by the attention that they receive from bystanders," those who witness bullying can "blatantly state that they don't think bullying is entertaining or funny," and perhaps even "create a distraction" to deny the bully attention. All of us can "commit to making it stop and consistently support the bullied candidate."
I'm prepared to do my part. Note that I haven't called Trump a bully but rather, as StopBullying.gov suggests, "the candidate who bullied." To label him a bully is to "send the message that the candidate's behavior cannot change." And I'd like to believe that everybody has the capacity for growth even Trump.