Jeb Bush formally ended his campaign for president on Saturday night after a dismal showing in South Carolina's primary. But, it had been clear for months that Bush's chances of being the Republican presidential nominee were close to zero.
How did the man who entered the race in the summer of last year as the clear favorite - with the famous last name, money at the ready and a resume of policy innovations and successes - wind up as an afterthought in the race long before voters actually started voting?
The reasons are many and complex but, at root, all come back to this basic fact: Jeb Bush is a fundamentally decent man who was badly miscast in the 2016 presidential race.
Bush was - and is - a soft spoken policy wonk raised in a family that produced not one but two presidents. He is polite. You might even describe him as genteel. He is a rule-follower. And he is simply not all that into the campaigning end of politics.
Bush's long-held and well known disdain for the nitty-gritty of modern campaigns was why I was stunned when it became clear in early 2015 that he was going to run for the Republican nomination. But, even then there were signs that Bush might not fully grasp the realities of the modern campaign.
"The decision will be based on 'can I do it joyfully' because I think we need to have candidates lift our spirits," Bush told CNN way back in January 2014 when talking about whether he would run for president. By December of that year - when it was clear Bush was all but in - he told a group of CEOs that "I kinda know how a Republican can win, whether it's me or somebody else - and it has to be much more uplifting, much more positive, much more willing to be, 'lose the primary to win the general' without violating your principles."
Bush's first forays as an actual candidate - he didn't announce formally until June 15 but was running hard long before that - affirmed the sense that he just might be out of his depth in the race. He was halting and awkward - at times seemingly baffled by the angry, in-your-face conservatism that confronted him on the campaign trail. His allies insisted this was all the result of a bit of rust; after all, Bush hadn't run for any office since 2002. He would get better, they insisted. Plus, his Right to Rise super PAC was on its way to raising $100 million in the first six months of 2015 - an insurance policy against any problems Jeb might have as a candidate.
What no one in Bush world - most of all Bush himself - seemed to grasp is how much the Republican party had changed in the decade since he had left the Florida governor's office. The presidency of Barack Obama had radicalized the GOP, making its base not only more conservative but more desirous of extreme rhetoric to counter the frustration and fury that Obama and his policies had created in them. The Republican base no longer wanted politicians who could offer up alternative policy solutions to undo what Obama had done. They wanted someone who would blow everything up. Everything.
Enter Donald Trump. Trump got into the race on June 16, one day after Bush - a remarkable symmetry given how big a role Trump played in Bush's demise.
At the start, Bush - and virtually everyone else in Republican politics - regarded Trump as a sideshow, an entertainer whose bombastic rhetoric would go nowhere. Bush ignored him.
Trump, from the start however, was focused on Bush, who he dismissed as a "low energy" candidate relying entirely on his family connections. In many ways, Trump defined his candidacy as the antidote for Bush-ism: An anti-establishment truth teller who was dependent on no one other than his own deep pockets. Trump's attacks on Bush's family - most notably his insistence that George W. Bush had not kept the country safe because of the Sept. 11, 2001 terrorist attacks - were a sign of just how deep his animosity toward the Bushes went.
It worked. And worked. By the time Bush and his team finally came around to the realization that Trump wasn't going away and that the former Florida governor needed to take Trump on rather than ignore him, it was already too late. Trump had effectively cast Bush as the sort of wishy-washy, boring and cautious politician that Republicans had been shoving down the throat of its base for years.
Bush tried to shake the patrician label but he was visibly uncomfortable as an attack dog. "Donald Trump is a jerk," became a favorite Bush line on the stump, an "attack" that only seemed to reinforce the idea of Jeb as too kind for the race he was running in. (If "jerk" is the worst thing you can say about someone, then you really aren't saying much bad at all.)
For the last six months - at least - it was clear that Bush was effectively an afterthought in the race - passed not only by Trump and conservative favorite Ted Cruz but also, most gallingly for Bush, by his one-time Florida mentee Marco Rubio. (Rubio's smackdown of Bush in a late October debate - "The only reason you're [attacking me] now is because we're running for the same position. Someone convinced you attacking me is going to help you" - served as a dramatic the-student-has-now-become-the-master moment.)
While Bush, smartly, turned all of his rhetorical fire on Trump over the final two (or so) months of his campaign, his super PAC bafflingly continued on a deeply misguided strategy of bashing Rubio, Cruz and even John Kasich. Trump was largely ignored by Right to Rise's tens of millions of dollars in attack ads, a giant mistake given that the only possible path to a Bush comeback was to destabilize the race by dethroning Trump.
Bush's sixth place finish in Iowa surprised no one. His fourth place finish - edging out the fading Rubio - in New Hampshire only prolonged the misery. As soon as polls closed at 7 pm eastern in South Carolina on Saturday, it was clear that the surprise Bush was hoping for wasn't coming.
His speech suspending his campaign was moving and heartfelt - a man with a genuine commitment to public service and to the conservative cause faced with the blunt reality that now was simply not his time.
"I have had a front row seat to this office for much of my adult life," Bush said. "I have seen fallible men rise up to the challenges of our time, with humility, and clarity of purpose . . . to make our nation safer, stronger, and freer."
And, he clearly had Trump on his mind even in his last moments as a candidate. "I firmly believe the American people must entrust this office to someone who understands that whoever holds it is the servant, not the master," Bush said.
Jeb Bush leaves the presidential race badly bruised by a Republican electorate who seems to want a bar-room brawler, not the captain of the fencing team as its nominee. His campaign deserves blame for not realizing that Trump was serious from the get-go and not adjusting Jeb's gentlemanly pitch to better fit the electorate. But, at the most fundamental level, who Jeb Bush has been for the entirety of his 63 years on earth was at odds with what Republican voters wanted in this election.
This was a wrong place, wrong time race for Jeb. He was never, ever going to win in a year like this one. Unfortunately, he realized that after suffering through a series of humiliations that added up to a campaign for president.
• 02/18/16: Senate Republicans will never hold a Supreme Court vote this year. This poll shows why
• 02/17/16: South Carolina isn't Bush Country anymore
• 02/12/16: Winners and losers from the 6th Dem debate
• 02/10/16: Winners and losers from the New Hampshire primary
• 02/06/16: Winners and losers from the fifth Democratic presidential debate
• 01/29/16: Winners and losers from the 7th Republican presidential debate
• 01/27/16: Ranking the Republican 2016 field
• 01/25/16: Trump is the favorite to be the Republican nominee. Period
• 01/22/16: Who had the worst week in Washington? Hillary Clinton
• 01/18/16: Feeling bad for Jeb Bush
• 01/15/16: Winners and losers from the sixth Republican presidential debate
• 01/12/16: Here's exactly how Bernie Sanders can beat Hillary Clinton
• 01/11/16:The fantasy scenario that could become reality for Hillary
• 12/30/15: The five big lessons from a weirdly watchable year of politics
• 12/21/15: Winners and losers in the third Democratic presidential debate
• 12/16/15: Winners and losers from the 5th Republican presidential debate
• 12/16/15: Cruz, not Trump, looking like GOP favorite for 2016
• 12/04/15: Ted Cruz is the sleeping giant in the Republican race
• 11/24/15:Trump is leading an increasingly fact-free 2016 campaign
• 11/23/15: A ranking of GOP presidential candidates who can still make a case --- and the nominee
• 11/16/15: The remarkably unappealing anger of Donald Trump
• 11/11/15: Winners and losers from the fourth Republican debate
• 11/02/15: Jeb Bush says he still doesn't get why his terrible debate performance matters so much
• 10/29/15: Winners and losers from the third Republican presidential debate
• 10/22/15: Paul Ryan might be saving his party. But at what cost?
• 10/20/15: Six things we know Joe Biden is thinking
• 10/19/15: Who had the worst week in Washington? Lincoln Chafee
• 10/14/15: Winners and losers from the first Dem presidential debate