Wednesday

October 20th, 2021

Insight

American innovative power's path to better days

Joel Zinberg, M.D., J.D.

By Joel Zinberg, M.D., J.D. City Journal

Published Dec. 21, 2020

American innovative power's path to better days
It seems like a lifetime, but it was only one year ago that the world learned about a cluster of pneumonia cases linked to a live animal market in Wuhan, China. The cause: a new coronavirus, SARS-CoV-2, that leads to a disease called Covid-19. Fast forward one year, and the U.S., as of mid-December, has seen more than 300,000 Covid-19 deaths and more than 17 million confirmed cases—but also remarkable scientific innovation and reasons for optimism.

Much has changed. An economy that was humming along with record-low unemployment was voluntarily shut down in an attempt to mitigate viral spread and the death toll. Unemployment soared to depression levels, and GDP cratered. In many areas, a third of small businesses have permanently closed. Children have missed nearly a year of in-person school, with short- and long-term effects on their social and educational development and economic prospects. The pandemic deepened political fissures and became the leading issue in the 2020 election, likely leading to President Donald Trump’s reelection defeat.

People were admonished to “follow the science,” though the science was unclear and constantly in flux. The pandemic has confounded experts’ recommendations and predictions. Infections, hospitalizations, and deaths are up around the country, regardless of the approaches that different states have taken. New Mexico, for example, adopted aggressive restrictions, including a mask mandate, self-quarantine orders for travelers, and a ban on public gatherings early on. Yet statewide infections and deaths climbed to new heights in October and November.

New York, where Governor Andrew Cuomo prides himself on his tough-love approach to public health, has the second-highest number of deaths per 100,000 citizens (184) in the country, edged out only by New Jersey (201). Florida has faced considerable criticism for imposing restrictions too late and for opening up too soon; yet the Sunshine State has less than half as many deaths (94) per 100,000.

Worldwide, the picture is similar. The U.S. has 96 deaths per 100,000 population, less than Belgium (158), Italy (111), and Spain (104), but roughly in line with the United Kingdom (97), the Czech Republic (95), and France (91). Sweden, relentlessly criticized for not taking adequate measures to limit infections, has only four-fifths as many deaths per capita (79) as the United States. Cases and deaths are now surging worldwide.

Nonetheless, we now appear closer to the end of the pandemic than to the beginning, thanks to the innovative power of the market to discover, develop, and provide lifesaving products. It usually takes ten years to develop vaccines for new diseases caused by novel viruses. Now, only ten months after SARS-CoV-2 was identified, 53 Covid-19 vaccines are being tested worldwide. Nearly a dozen have reached Phase III, the most advanced trial stage. Two companies, Pfizer and Moderna, already have demonstrated that their vaccines work at more than 90 percent effectiveness, with limited and mild side effects, and have just received emergency-use authorizations from the Food and Drug Administration. The companies say that they can supply approximately 45 million doses, enough to vaccinate more than 20 million people, before the end of 2020, and more than 1 billion doses in 2021. A third company, Astra-Zeneca, is not far behind.

Developing new treatments and diagnostic testing is also normally a years-long process. But multiple new treatments, such as antibodies from Eli Lilly and Regeneron and Gilead’s antiviral remdesivir, have been approved and employed. Several new diagnostic tests have also been approved.

New vaccines will be used in a population that has already had significant exposure to SARS-CoV-2. The CDC is now estimating that eight times as many people may have been infected as there are confirmed Covid-19 cases. This is consistent with earlier estimates that the true number of people infected with SARS-CoV-2 had been substantially underestimated. Since the U.S. now has confirmed more than 17 million Covid-19 cases, more than 100 million people, or nearly a third of the population, may have already been infected and developed antibodies. We may be nearly halfway toward reaching the 60 percent to 70 percent of the population needed for herd immunity. Only 100 million previously uninfected Americans might need to be vaccinated with a highly effective vaccine to halt the pandemic.

The biggest problem we now face is ensuring that enough people are willing to be vaccinated.

Sign up for the daily JWR update. It's free. Just click here.

Joe Biden’s presidential campaign, scientists allied with the campaign, and other leaders, like New York governor Cuomo, have undermined confidence in prospective vaccines by suggesting that the FDA and vaccine developers were disregarding safety and moving too fast to approve. Despite pledges from vaccine developers and reassurances from FDA leadership that established safety and effectiveness standards would be observed, the Pew Research Center found that the number of Americans who would definitely or probably be vaccinated fell from 72 percent in May to 51 percent in September. Continued partisan attacks like Cuomo’s recent call to delay vaccine distribution by the Trump administration have likely further eroded public trust.

It remains to be seen what the Biden administration will do. The president-elect’s Covid-19 plan is long on promises and short on details. Many items—like advancing adoption of telehealth, accelerating spending on the development of treatments and vaccines, working with private companies to expand provision of personal protective equipment, providing surge capacity for treatment, creating loan facilities for small and midsize businesses, and making testing widely available—have already been implemented by the Trump administration.


Some others, like rejoining the World Health Organization, will make little impact on the immediate course of the pandemic, to say nothing of suggestions such as investing in infrastructure, “encourag[ing] union organizing to defend collective bargaining,” and fighting climate change, which have nothing to do with the pandemic. And still other priorities, like restoring the National Security Council Directorate for Global Health Security and Biodefense, are window dressing—the directorate was reorganized, but the NSC personnel who manned it stayed in the NSC and performed the same security and biodefense roles outside a formal directorate.

Biden has suggested a national mask mandate, but no clear statutory or constitutional authority exists for the federal government to impose one. The Constitution reserves to the states police powers to protect public health. Further, a national mask mandate would make little difference, since 38 states, the District of Columbia, and Puerto Rico already have mask mandates.

Evidence for the effectiveness of masks is also limited and much stronger in medical-care settings, where masks are already universally used, than in community settings.

The United States has endured much in 2020. But now, thanks to our innovative market economy and the fortitude of our citizens, we can see a path to better days.


Previously:
07/27/20: Science's dirty secret: Medical evidence is not always clear, and it rarely mandates a clear policy direction

07/13/20: Death By Policy: Mortality statistics show that many people have died from lockdown-related causes, not from Covid-19

(COMMENT, BELOW)

Joel Zinberg, M.D., J.D., is a Senior Fellow at the Competitive Enterprise Institute in Washington, D.C., and an associate clinical professor of surgery at the Mount Sinai Icahn School of Medicine in New York. He served as general counsel and senior economist at the Council of Economic Advisers from 2017 to 2019, where he specialized in health policy. He wrote this for City Journal.

Columnists

Toons

Lifestyles