Wednesday

October 20th, 2021

Insight

The first and now the last best hope of the Arab Spring is at risk

 Bobby Ghosh

By Bobby Ghosh Bloomberg View

Published July 28, 2021

The first and now the last best hope of the Arab Spring is at risk
Amid Tunisia's political upheaval, it is easy to hear echoes of the events in Egypt eight years ago. In the summer of 2013, widespread protests against an unpopular Islamist government allowed General Abdel-Fattah el-Sissi to take power in what amounted to a coup.

Tunisia's President Kais Saied may not wear military fatigues, but he's doing a pretty good el-Sissi impression nonetheless: Taking advantage of demonstrations against an unpopular Islamist-backed government, he has suspended the country's elected parliament and sacked the prime minister, effectively assuming dictatorial authority over the country.

Only months ago, Tunisia was being celebrated anew as the only country that remained a democracy in the decade after the Arab Spring. There is a real risk the gains secured then may now be lost, just as they were in Egypt. The task of forestalling that dreadful outcome falls again to the Tunisians who overthrew their dictator in January 2011, and to the two institutions that played pivotal roles back then: the military and the labor unions.

The military had refused the dictator's orders to crack down on the protests, and the labor organizations had ensured a smooth transition to civilian rule — for which four groups, known collectively as the National Dialogue Quartet, were awarded the Nobel Peace Price in 2015.


How will the forces that coalesced during the Arab Spring respond to this summer of discontent? The early signs are not good.

Saied's power grab has been welcomed in the streets by the anti-government protesters. Fed up by the serial failures of the leaders they elected — unemployment, one of the root causes of the Arab Spring, remains rampant — many Tunisians are inclined to give their president the benefit of the doubt. He has portrayed himself as incorruptible and unconnected to the political parties that have let them down. He says he will appoint a new prime minister, but didn't say when. Nor has he indicated when or if parliament would be reconvened.

He also seems to have coopted the military, giving it the crucial responsibility for administering the national vaccination program last week. The generals, having fallen in lockstep behind the president, can expect to be rewarded with even more responsibilities in the days ahead.

The Tunisian General Labour Union, the country's largest, most powerful labor organization and one of the four Nobel winners, has adopted a wait-and-see posture. Better known by its French acronym UGTT, it has issued only a vague statement about the importance of "constitutional legitimacy" and the need for national dialogue.

Sign up for the daily JWR update. It's free. Just click here.

But all three forces — the protesters, the military and the unions — will face tougher tests in the days ahead. The political forces that dominate parliament have denounced Saied's actions as a coup. It is only a matter of time before Ennahda, the main Islamist party, and secular groups mount demonstrations of their own.

The protesters who celebrated the suspension of democracy will then have to decide whether they will return to the street to defend the president, triggering a face-off with great potential for violence. If he sticks to the el-Sissi playbook, Saied will order a crackdown against his opponents, putting the military in a familiar quandary of whether to protect the people or the president.

But most likely, the decisive part will be played by the unions. The presence of strong, politically active civil-society institutions was the key differentiator between Tunisia and Egypt in the aftermath of the Arab Spring, and it might be decisive again. Much will depend on the disposition of the UGTT, which represents most of the country's civil service and has a demonstrated capacity to bring all of Tunisia to a standstill.

This gives it the power, if it is so minded, to prevent Saied from fully reprising el-Sissi's repression of the political opposition. That's why Ennahda's leader, Rachid Ghannouchi, in his first reaction to Saied's announcement, appealed to the UGTT's secretary general, Noureddine Taboubi, "to restore democracy."

To do so would require exercising some muscle memory. Since it was ennobled in 2015, the UGTT has receded into its role as a union. More often than not, it has been a hindrance to progress in Tunisia, standing foursquare against much-needed economic reforms such as paring down the civil service and selling off state enterprises.

But its leadership takes great pride in its history as an anti-colonial force before Tunisia's 1956 independence from the French, and in its more recent function as a check on government power. As one top leader told me two years ago: "UGTT is different from any union in the world. We fight not just for bread and clothing, but for national dignity."

It's time for the UGTT to suit up for that fight again.

(COMMENT, BELOW)

Bobby Ghosh is an Indian-born American journalist and commentator. He is a columnist and member of the editorial board at Bloomberg Opinion, writing on foreign affairs, with a special focus on the Middle East and the wider Islamic world. Starting in 2016, Ghosh was editor-in-chief of the Hindustan Times and TIME Magazine's World Editor.


Previously:
07/15/21: No joy for Iran over the Taliban romp next door
07/07/21: Why Macron and Erdogan are suddenly playing nice
06/17/21: Iran's election is all about Supreme Leader's toxic legacy
08/17/20: Macron's muscle-flexing will make Mediterranean tensions worse
08/06/20: Beirut explosions create a dilemma for the world
06/25/20: Egypt's el-Sissi suffers a stunning reversal of fortunes
05/05/20: The Saudis' defacto leader is stuck exactly where Trump wants him
04/20/20: Trump is right to block IMF aid for Iran
02/17/20: Algeria wants a role in Libya that it can't afford
02/06/20: Iraq's new prime minister may not last long
01/27/20: Libya deal is a gentleman's bargain between rogues
01/20/20: Europe's lack of resolve is revealing --- to Iran
01/14/20: Iran isn't facing a 'Chernobyl moment'

Columnists

Toons

Lifestyles