Clicking on banner ads keeps JWR alive
Jewish World Review May 29, 2001 /7 Sivan, 5761

Debra J. Saunders

Debra J. Saunders
JWR's Pundits
World Editorial
Cartoon Showcase

Mallard Fillmore

Michael Barone
Mona Charen
Linda Chavez
Ann Coulter
Greg Crosby
Larry Elder
Don Feder
Suzanne Fields
James Glassman
Paul Greenberg
Bob Greene
Betsy Hart
Nat Hentoff
David Horowitz
Marianne Jennings
Michael Kelly
Mort Kondracke
Ch. Krauthammer
Lawrence Kudlow
Dr. Laura
John Leo
David Limbaugh
Michelle Malkin
Chris Matthews
Michael Medved
Kathleen Parker
Sam Schulman
Amity Shlaes
Roger Simon
Tony Snow
Thomas Sowell
Cal Thomas
Jonathan S. Tobin
Ben Wattenberg
George Will
Bruce Williams
Walter Williams
Mort Zuckerman

Consumer Reports

Operation: Beat up on civil rights -- OAKLAND mayor Jerry Brown is a big booster of the city's "Operation Beat Feet" program that allows the city to seize cars driven by those who solicit prostitutes or try to buy drugs on the street. Said Dao Mayor, "We're going to keep it going as long as we have to, until these neighborhoods are safe."

I'm all for safe Oakland neighborhoods too, but not if it means punishing innocent people, and not if it means the punishment far exceeds the crime.

The program was started with good intentions. Alameda County Deputy District Attorney Russ Giuntini said he first suggested such a program to the city because predominantly black flatland neighborhoods were beset with white out-of-towners looking for drugs. It didn't seem fair.

"To me, the ultimate question is, who's got the choice?" he explained. "Is it the person who's on a low- or fixed-income renting or owning a home in the flatlands, or is it the person who, on the way home decides, 'I'm going to buy some rock cocaine or look for a prostitute.'"

That's the image the forfeiture folk like to leave you with: rich swell from Tiburon loses his luxury car after he's caught trolling Oakland for drugs or demeaning sex.

City documents, however, don't support that stereotype. For one thing, the person who loses the car probably wasn't even in it. Only about 150 of the 351 vehicles seized were registered to the suspect, according to a KTVU-Chronicle review.

Seizure of property from people who didn't do anything is "constitutional," Giuntini noted. Too true. In an outrageous 1996 ruling, the U.S. Supreme Court upheld the seizure of a 1977 Pontiac co-owned by the wife of a man who solicited a prostitute in Detroit. As if the news about her husband's hobby wasn't bad enough, Tina Bennis had to bundle up all four of her children to walk the two eldest to school each morning because authorities had seized the family's first-ever second car. Shame on the Big Bench for supporting laws that punish innocent people.

Despite the rhetoric, most of the cars seized in Oakland fit the Bennis Pontiac profile.

KTVU Producer Roland De Wolk found that the average value of cars seized was $1,210 which, Mill Valley attorney Brenda Grantland noted, means that too often it is cheaper to buy back your clunker -- or allow the city to auction it off and buy another -- than it is to defend yourself.

Grantland defended a man whose $5,000 truck was seized after he tried to buy $20 worth of marijuana. She successfully argued that because the criminal fine for trying to buy small amounts of marijuana is $50, the forfeiture violated the Eighth Amendment's excessive fines clause. One problem, she noted: "It cost us more than the value of the truck to litigate the case."

(Plus, her client still had to pay $2,500 to Oakland to get back his truck, when the fine is supposed to be $50.)

Oakland Deputy City Attorney Pelayo Llamas Jr. said the Grantland case proved "a perfect example of someone taking advantage of their due process rights." Due process rights? Ha. Tell that to a man who has to pay a fine 500 times the fine demanded of other violators. Tell that to the wife of a guy who got caught doing what he shouldn't be doing -- when she has to give up her car because she couldn't find a lawyer who would represent her for less than her clunker is worth.

Comment JWR contributor Debra J. Saunders's column by clicking here.


05/24/01: Of puppies, kittens and huge credit-card debts
05/22/01: Bush needs an energy tinkerbell
05/18/01: Divided we stand, united they fall
05/16/01: Big Bench backs might over right
05/15/01: Close SUV loophole
05/11/01: Kill the test, welcome failure
05/09/01: DA mayor's disappointing legacy
05/07/01: If it ain't broken ...
05/03/01: They shoot civilians, don't they?
04/30/01: Executions are not for prime time
04/12/01: White House and the green myth
04/10/01: The perjurer as celeb
04/04/01: Bush bashers don't know squat
04/02/01: Drugging our oldsters
03/30/01: Robert Lee Massie exercises his death wish
03/28/01: Cheney's nuclear reactor
03/26/01: Where California and Mexico meet
03/16/01: Boy's sentence was no accident
03/14/01: Soft money, hard reform
03/12/01: Banks, big credit lines and consumer bankruptcy
03/09/01: Free speech dies in Berkeley
03/02/01: When rats have rights
02/28/01: Move a frog, go to jail?
02/26/01: They knew they'd get away with it
02/20/01: How Dems define tax fairness
02/16/01: The jackpot casino Carmel tribe?
02/14/01: You can fight school success
02/12/01: Hannibal -- with guts this time
02/08/01: A family of jailbirds
02/05/01: Reality's most demeaning TV moments
02/01/01: Justice for the non-Rich
01/26/01: Hail to the chiefs of D.C. opinion
01/24/01: A day of mud and monuments
01/22/01: Diversity, division, de-lovely D.C.
01/19/01: Parties agree: Give back the money
01/17/01: Get tough with the oil companies, or forget pumping more Alaskan crude
01/15/01: Mineta better pray that no attending confirmation senator has ever driven to San Jose during rush hour
01/12/01: Europeans should look in the mirror
01/10/01: Dems' reasons for dissin' Dubya's picks
01/08/01: Jerry, curb your guru
01/03/01: A foe of Hitler and friend of Keating
12/28/00: Nice people think nice thoughts
12/26/00: The Clinton years: Epilogue
12/21/00: 'Tis the season to free nonviolent drug offenders 12/18/00: A golden opportunity is squandered
12/15/00: You can take the 24 years, good son
12/13/00: Court of law vs. court of public opinion
12/08/00: A salvo in the war on the war on drugs
12/06/00: Don't cry, Butterfly: Big trees make great decks
12/04/00: Florida: Don't do as Romans did
11/30/00: Special City's hotel parking ticket
11/27/00: No means yes, yes means more than yes
11/22/00: The bench, the ballot and fairness
11/20/00: Mendocino, how green is your ballot?

© 2000, Creators Syndicate