
 |
|
July 2, 2009
Rabbi Abraham J. Twerski: The hallmark of a person
Abe Novick: Up, up, and aliya
July 1, 2009
Rabbi Avi Shafran: The Road Taken
The Kosher Gourmet
by Marialisa Calta: Get into the holiday spirit with these Star-Spangled desserts
June 30, 2009
Rabbi Binyomin Ginsberg: What makes a great parent?
Caroline B. Glick: Ideologue-in-Chief
June 29, 2009
The Jewish Ethicist
by Rabbi Dr. Asher Meir: Beware of 'Caveat Emptor'
Steven Emerson: ACLU pushing for more money for Hamas
June 26, 2009
Rabbi Yoni Posnick: Learn the secret to a healthy marriage from a scriptural villain
Caroline B. Glick: Barack Obama vs. International Law
June 25, 2009
Rabbi Shimon Apisdorf: The Absurd Power of Truth
Jordan "Gorf" Gorfinkle's strip:
Everything's Relative
June 24, 2009
Rabbi Yonason Goldson: Advancement of technology is a wake-up call for humanity
The Kosher Gourmet by Andrea Weigl: Summer on a stick: Making frozen treats can be easy, creative and fun
June 23, 2009
Martin M. Bodek: 'On Surnames': And so, We Begin
Caroline B. Glick: The Obama Effect
June 22, 2009
The Jewish Ethicist by Rabbi Dr. Asher Meir: Working for a corrupt firm
N. Richard Greenfield : Where are American Jews?
June 19, 2009
Rabbi Abraham J. Twerski: Emotion v. intellect
Caroline B. Glick: Israel's rare opportunity
June 18, 2009
Jonathan Rosenblum: Sometimes it is more essential to define the nature of evil than good
Jordan "Gorf" Gorfinkle's strip:
Everything's Relative
June 17, 2009
Rabbi Yonason Goldson: The Language of Confusion
The Kosher Gourmet by Linda Gassenheimer: Nothing pleases Dad more than a thick, juicy onion-smothered steak. Add home-Baked Potato Chips and …
June 16, 2009
The Jewish Ethicist by Rabbi Dr. Asher Meir: Career v. Careersism
Caroline B. Glick: Obama's losing streak and Israel
Richard Z. Chesnoff: Palestinians: Never Missing an Opportunity …
June 15, 2009
Israeli Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu: How Judea and Samaria can become 'Palestine'
Daniel Pipes: Where Netanyahu's speech failed
June 12, 2009
Rabbi Abraham J. Twerski: Some big thoughts about not acting so big
Caroline B. Glick:
Obama's High Commissioner
June 11, 2009
Victor Davis Hanson: Our historically challenged President
Mitch Albom: Beware the True Believers
Lewis Grossberger: What we learn from the new Hitler photos
June 10, 2009
Mort Zuckerman: What Obama and his advisors won't -- or refuse to -- grasp about Israel and the Muslim world
The Kosher Gourmet
by Steve Petusevsky Lotsa pasta: Tips, techniques and (amazing) taste
June 9, 2009
Anne Bayefsky: Obama's stunning offense to Israel and the Jewish people
Frank J. Gaffney, Jr.: America's first Muslim president?
June 8, 2009
The Jewish Ethicist by Rabbi Dr. Asher Meir: Merchant must take responsibility for careless shopper?
Mark Steyn: A superpower that feeds on mediocrity cannot survive for long on leftovers from the past
Richard Z. Chesnoff: How do you say 'kumbaya' in Arabic?
June 5, 2009
Rabbi Abraham J. Twerski: In quest of spirituality
Caroline B. Glick: Obama's Arabian dreams
Charles Krauthammer: The Settlements Myth
June 4, 2009
Paul Greenberg: The War Comes to Little Rock
The Kosher Gourmet
by Judy Hevrdejs: Splash it on! Tap your inner jazz musician and improvise when stirring up a vinaigrette
June 3, 2009
The Jewish Ethicist by Rabbi Dr. Asher Meir: Q. Should terrible teacher be exposed?
Jonathan Rosenblum: The Israel Lobby: Missing in Action
June 2, 2009
Dennis Prager: The Speech President Obama Won't Dare Give in Egypt
Frank J. Gaffney, Jr.: Pressure on Israel raises war risk
Oct. 29, 2003
Mortimer B. Zuckerman: Graffiti On History's Walls (MUST-READ!)
|
| |
Jewish World Review
Sept. 12, 2007
/ 29 Elul, 5767
The End of the Bargain
By
Jonathan Rosenblum
More than half of Jews under 35 would not view the destruction of Israel as a personal tragedy, according to a recent report. The exception were the Orthodox. What makes them different and what can the Jewish establishment learn from them?
http://www.JewishWorldReview.com |
Sociologists Stephen Cohen and Ari Kelman have now confirmed what everyone
already knew: Young American Jews do not care very much about Israel. They
are not just apathetic about Israel, that indifference is "giving way to
downright alienation," write Cohen and Kelman.
More than half of Jews under 35 said that they would not view the
destruction of Israel as a personal tragedy. The death and expulsion of
millions is something they could live with. By those standards, they
probably would not see the Holocaust as a "personal" tragedy either.
"These results are very upsetting," said Jewish Agency chairman Zev Bielski.
He then proceeded to give an inane explanation for those numbers: the
comfortable life of most American Jews.
Cohen and Kelman know better. And their answer is summed up in the
demographic they did not interview for their study: Orthodox Jews. A survey
of young Orthodox Jews would have yielded a diametrically opposed and highly
embarrassing result.
Among younger Jews, those for whom their Judaism is important primarily
the Orthodox will remain connected to the fate of their fellow Jews in
Israel. Most Orthodox American youth will study in Israel after high school,
some for many years. And almost all will visit Israel many times. Eretz
Yisrael is not a mere abstraction for them, but the center of the spiritual
life of the Jewish people.
Even an anti-Zionist Satmar chassid living in the secluded village of Monroe
will intensify his prayers when Israel is at war and follow the action
closely. Why? Because for him the name Jew means something.
The majority of young American Jews and the majority of young Israelis share
in common a lack of interest in their Judaism. But that shared negativity
provides little basis for a relationship. Shared gene pools won't do it
either that smacks of racism. And ethnic identity, it turns out, cannot be
passed down, or survive the breakup of ethnically homogeneous neighborhoods.
What young Jews under 35 feel towards Israel goes beyond apathy to outright
resentment. Israel complicates their social lives and muddies their
political identity. Only 54% profess to be comfortable with the idea of a
Jewish state at all. In Europe and on elite American campuses,
internationalism and a world-without-borders are the rage. The Jews of
Israel, with their stubborn insistence on protecting their nation-state,
are, as always, out-of-sync.
Young American Jews do not wish to be tarred with their atavisms. On campus
and where enlightened folk meet, Israel is scorned as a colonial oppressor.
Who wants to be identified as a sympathizer with apartheid? Once Reform
Judaism disavowed Zionism for fear of being thought disloyal to their host
countries, and young American Jews today share similar fears of being out of
step with their enlightened peers.
Molly Umberger, whose mother is program director of the leftist New Israel
Fund (NIF), told the Jerusalem Post that she views both Israel and
Palestinians as having made lots of mistakes and the situation as
complicated, but generally "tries not to think about [ Israel]." (No wonder
when Bruce Temkin, the director of the NIF, describes Israel as a
"turn-off.") Daniel Alperin, 33, describes his interest in Israel as waning
when he began to hear "the bad stuff" probably about the time he entered
college.
Already the trends lines were pointing in this direction forty years ago. In
a 1965 Commentary symposium of younger Jewish intellectuals the least
religiously identified segment of American Jewry only one expressed
complete comfort with Israel's creation and pride in its accomplishments,
and he eventually made aliyah. The rest expressed various degrees of
discomfort with Israel's militarism (and this was before 1967 and the
"occupation"). The only Jewish identity they acknowledged at all was that of
the "Jew" as the perpetually alienated critic of those in power not
exactly one upon which to base a connection to other Jews. Now the rest of
American Jewry is catching up to those once young intellectuals.
The implications of Cohen and Kelman's findings for American Jewry are
great. The historic bargain linking American Jewry and Israel since the
founding of the State is coming to an end. The terms of the deal were
unspoken, but clear: Israel would provide American Jews with a sense of
pride and identity as Jews, and they, in turn, would shower upon Israel
their financial and political support. But Israel is no longer a source of
pride for non-Orthodox Jews, and the identity it provides is not one which
they wish to share.
But the survey signals something else as well: a declining understanding on
the part of American Jews of Judaism in terms of a national identity that
imposes obligations to one's co-nationals.. That is being replaced by a
return to the self-definition of classic German Reform: German (or in this
case American) nationals of the Mosaic persuasion.
Cohen and Kelman are wrong to argue that ethnic identity is being replaced
by religious identity. For when young American Jews say that they view their
Judaism as a religious not national identity, the religion they refer to is
a pretty tepid affair. Precisely because it is so tepid does it fail to
provide them a sense of connection to their fellow Jews, whether in America
or abroad. It is a religion largely lacking connection to the Land of
Israel, and even more importantly to the defining event in Jewish history
the giving of Torah at Sinai. Absent the latter, there is no common mission
to link the descendants of those who stood at Sinai.
The impact of the declining sense of responsibility to one's fellow Jews is
being felt within American Jewry itself, not just in attitudes towards
Israel. Already only 6% of giving by mega-Jewish foundations goes to
remotely Jewish causes. It is hardly surprising, for instance, that
non-Jewish spouses are not eager to contribute to Jewish causes. In time,
funding the institutions of American Jewry will become ever more difficult.
And the Orthodox will be left to donate to Israel.
The political implications for Israel are large as well. Fortunately,
Professors Walt and Mearsheimer are wrong about an Israel Lobby comprised
mostly of those with Jewish-sounding names. It is devout Christians, and not
some nefarious Israel Lobby, which is the primary bulwark of American
support for Israel today. That we have to rely on Christian support, rather
than our fellow Jews, however, is a very mixed blessing indeed.
Every weekday JewishWorldReview.com publishes inspiring articles. Sign up for our daily update. It's free. Just click here.
Comment by clicking here.
JWR contributor Jonathan Rosenblum is founder of Jewish Media Resources and a widely-read columnist for the Jerusalem Post's domestic and international editions and for the Hebrew daily Maariv. He is also a respected commentator on Israeli politics, society, culture and the Israeli legal system, who speaks frequently on these topics in the United States, Europe, and Israel. His articles appear regularly in numerous Jewish periodicals in the United States and Israel. Rosenblum is the author of seven biographies of major modern Jewish figures. He is a graduate of the University of Chicago and Yale Law School. Rosenblum lives in Jerusalem with his wife and eight children.

© 2007, Jonathan Rosenblum
|