 |
|
February 13, 2012
Binyamin Rose: Back to the Bunker: How a life-risking act by a Christian family during the Holocaust saved a family and built a thriving community a world away
Menachem Wecker: Business Schools Teach Real Estate Despite Troubled Housing Market
February 10, 2012
Lisa M. Krieger: Man with defibrillator demands access to his own heart's information
David G. Savage: Why activists may not be in a hurry to have High Court rule on alternative marriage
February 9, 2012
Laura McMullen: 10 Least Expensive Public Schools for Out-of-State Students
Kimberly Palmer: How to actually enjoy -- relaxing, financially -- your vacation
February 8, 2012
Warren Richey: Why momentous Prop. 8 ruling might not satisfy gay-rights groups
Menachem Wecker: Though Controversial, LL.M.'s Can Lead to Specialized Legal Jobs
The Kosher Gourmet byDana Velden: Going to the bother of making soup? You know it better be good. This CREAM OF TOMATO SOUP certainly is! And it's a cinch to make, too (Includes techinques and serving secrets)
February 7, 2012
Frank J. Gaffney, Jr.: Caught off-guard? President's Super Bowl interview with Matt Lauer gives those who need a reason not to vote for him, a darn good one
Suzanne Bohan: Leaping lizards! Tiny reptiles advancing robot design
February 6, 2012
Jonathan Tobin: Iran Threatens Israel With Destruction, But the New York Times Doesn't Hear It
Jeffrey Fleishman: In newly democratic Egypt, tens of democracy activists jailed, to stand trial; their groups are 'threatening the stability of the homeland'
Julie Deardorff : Researchers say antioxidants may not be that effective and could do more harm than good
Mark Clayton: How did Anonymous hackers eavesdrop on FBI and Scotland Yard?
February 3, 2012
Edmund Sanders : Israeli official says Iran is creating missile that could reach East Coast of US
Victoria Kim: Immigrant-smuggling ring used black drivers to avoid racial profiling
February 2, 2012
Jim Carney: Wrong number call may have saved her life
Reza Kahlili : Ex-CIA spy in Iran's Revolutionary Guard: What Obama doesn't grasp about striking deals with Tehran
Tina Susman: For woodchuck rescuer, every day is Groundhog Day
February 1, 2012
Brian Bennett: US officials see increasing threat of domestic attack from Iran
Emily Brandon: How to Take Advantage of New 401(k) Fee Disclosures
January 31, 2012
January 30, 2012
Paul Richter and Ramin Mostaghim: Misreading Teheran's limits -- deadly and economically devastating as they may be -- is a risk administration, Europe seem willing to take
Suzanne Bohan: Warning: Nap-deprived tots missing more than sleep, study finds
Meg Handley: Banks Revamping Rewards Programs to Woo Customers
January 27, 2012
Caroline B. Glick: Obama: Of course I intend to prevent a nuclear holocaust . . . in a few months
Yochonon Donn: In liberal New York City, fervently-Orthodox Jews may soon be getting a district to call their own
Jeannine Stein: An inflated ego and thinking you're 'all that' doesn't just make others sick of you, it can make you ill
Katy Hopkins: New budget rules may affect how much money you get for college
January 26, 2012
Ed Koch: To the New York Times, calling for the murder of Jews by those capable of having their incitement taken seriously isn't news
Jeannine Stein: Mental illness struck one in five U.S. adults in 2010: Report
January 25, 2012
Richard Simon: House passes two bills endorsing the use of religious symbols at military memorials
Fred Weir: Putin: Multiethnic Russia cannot survive as a US-style 'melting pot'; must find its own way
Susan Johnston: 5 Sneaky Coupon Strategies Consumers Should Watch Out For
January 24, 2012
Carol Clark: The price of your soul: How your brain decides whether to 'sell out'
Caroline B. Glick: America lost most in 'Arab Spring'. Sadly, many voters still don't grasp the extent
Warren Richey: Drug criminal scores win in GPS ruling from conservative-leaning high court
Erika Bolstad: Black conservatives gather to talk about gaining strength
January 23, 2012
Melissa Dribben: Jewish voters to play a key role in Florida's Republican primary
Jordan Rau: In quest to grow, Catholic hospital system will announce this morning its break from church
Ali Safi: U.S. envoy gives Taliban terms for peace talks
January 19, 2012
January 18, 2012
January 17, 2012
Frank J. Gaffney Jr.: No-kidding red lines: U.S. response to an Iranian nuke may be bluster, but Israel's won't be
David G. Savage: They sued their principals after slandering them online --- now the cases are headed to the Supreme Court
David Francis: Where to Invest in 2012: With stocks expected to rebound, opportunity abounds for investors
January 13, 2012
Ben Lynfield: Israeli lawmakers move to annex Jewish Judea, one museum at a time
Alexia Elejalde-Ruiz: Thriving through touch: Gentle massage helps older people with low mobility improve in mind and body
January 12, 2012
Warren Richey: Landmark Supreme Court ruling a 'resounding win' for religious groups
Warren Richey: Supreme Court says no to new rule on eyewitness testimony
John Fauber : Statins found to raise diabetes risk in postmenopausal women
Katy Hopkins : Consider This Before You Pay for an Online Degree
The Kosher Gourmet by Joseph Erdos: This mushroom and barley soup has an intense -- almost nutty -- flavor that mixes robust with Middle East. It has creaminess without cream
January 11, 2012
Shari Roan: Millions of atrial fibrillation sufferers at risk for devastating, but preventable, stroke
Tom Hussain: Pakistan -- recipient of more than $21 billion in civilian and military aid -- speeds pursuit of Iranian pipeline, defying US
David G. Savage: High court signals it won't be loosening TV's 'indecency' rules
Stephen Ceasar: Oklahoma's Islamic law amendment can't go into effect, court rules
January 10, 2012
Reza Kahlili: From an ex-CIA spy: US must exploit new split in Iran's Revolutionary Guard
Karen Kaplan: Study: Nicotine replacement products ineffective when used in real-life situations
January 9, 2012
Michael Doyle: Put through legal hell over dream home, couple fought back hard --- all the way to Supreme Court
|
| |
Jewish World Review
January 21, 2008
/ 14 Shevat 5768
Almost-Poor
By
Rabbi Dr. Asher Meir
Should the lower-middle-class be eligible for credit and discounts?
http://www.JewishWorldReview.com |
Q: Our medical institution gives free care to the indigent, and those with health insurance obtain care through their plan. But what about people who aren't really poor but don't have the means to get really adequate insurance? They fall between the cracks.
A: The problem of the "almost poor" arises in many contexts. Recently, Harvard College extended its financial aid package to solidly middle-class families. They concluded that the college had become a place for the rich (who can afford it) and the poor (who are eligible for extensive aid), but had emptied out of the middle class.
This problem exists in Jewish law as well. In fact, the Mishna specifically states that there is a sharp boundary of eligibility for charity:
One who has 200 zuz [an amount sufficient for basic expenses for a year] may not take the dropped or forgotten sheaf, or the corner of the field [all these must be left for the poor] or the poor tithe. If he has even one dinar less and he is given even a thousand [zuz] in one sum, he may take it.
If [his assets] are liened to his creditor or to his wife's kesubah [support in case she is widowed or divorced], he may take. We do not compel him to sell his house or his [essential] furnishings. (1)
This is similar to your case: an impoverished person is entitled to free medical care, which can easily be worth five times a year's living expenses (the example given in the mishna). But a person who is not impoverished is entitled to nothing!
However, there are various alternative solutions to this problem.
First of all, we need to recognize that even in the case of the impoverished, Jewish law favors loans over gifts, at least when it comes to large amounts of aid. The dropped or forgotten sheaf and the corner of the field are generally small amounts which are enough only for subsistence; even the poor tithe is not usually a huge amount, and a thousand-zuz gift would be very unusual in practice. The very Torah verse which admonishes us to take care of all the needs of the poor speaks of loans, rather than outright charity:
When you will have a needy person from one of your brothers, in one of your gates in your land which the Lord your G-d gives you, don't harden your heart and don't shut your hand to your needy brother. Surely open your hand to him and lend to him enough for his needs, which are lacking to him (Deuteronomy 15:7-8).
So one practical solution is to offer people of limited means credit, by means of generous repayment terms, even if they are not eligible for a discount.
Another important consideration is that the commandment of charity is precisely "enough for his needs, which are lacking to him." Normally, a person with enough assets for subsistence is not needy, but a sick person has much greater needs. In this case, we fulfill the charity obligation even when we give to a person who would not normally be considered "poor", because in relationship to their extraordinary needs they are indeed lacking. So if it is possible to extend eligibility for aid to middle-class people who have extraordinary expenses this would be desirable
There is also an additional factor at work. Officially your practice defines the regular price as "full price", whereas indigent patients are treated pro bono. But in many cases the reality is that regular patients pay more than what the practice would charge if there were no pro bono cases, so in effect they are making two payments: one is a charge for service, the other a subsidy payment for poor patients.
In this case, it would be fair to charge the patient of limited means only the "true" charge. (This is not the same as "at cost" since you are not deducting your profit, only the subsidy portion.) Jewish law has a clear analog to this. In general every person has to give charity; the most common custom is to give a tenth of one's income by analogy to the poor tithe the Torah imposes on farmers. If a person is poor, then instead of giving charity he receives it. (Jewish law actually states that even a poor person who lives on charity has to give a token amount to charity, (2) since giving charity is a basic human need which is itself "his needs, which are lacking to him".)
But there is also an intermediate category of someone who is not rich enough to give charity and not poor enough to get it. It is appropriate to charge such a person the fee that would apply if there was no need to subsidize poorer patients.
Jewish tradition encourages generosity towards others and obliges us to provide for the poor, but it also educates us to strive for independence. There is no general obligation to give charity to those who are able to make ends meet, even if they have to struggle a bit. But it is certainly desirable to help such individuals out with credit. In addition, "poverty" has to be measured in relationship to a person's needs, and some medical treatments are enough to impoverish even a middle class family. So when expensive treatments are needed even such a family may be considered "needy" for the purposes of giving charity.
Finally, while the almost-poor aren't eligible to receive charity, they are also not obliged to give it (beyond a token amount). So it is desirable to give such individuals a "discount" to credit them for any part of the regular fee which you would consider a kind of subsidy to enable you to provide pro bono services.
SOURCES: (1) Mishna, Peah 8:8 (2) Babylonian Talmud, Gittin 7b
ARCHIVES
Every weekday JewishWorldReview.com publishes inspiring articles. Sign up for our daily update. It's free. Just click here.
JWR contributor Rabbi Dr. Asher Meir, formerly of the Council of Economic Advisers in the Reagan
administration, is Research Director of the Business Ethics Center of Jerusalem, Jerusalem College of Technology.
To comment or pose a question, please click here.
THE JEWISH ETHICIST, NOW IN BOOK FORM
You've enjoyed his columns on JWR for years. Now the Jewish Ethicist has culled his most intriguing — and controversial — offerings in book form.
HARDCOVER
PAPERBACK
Sales help fund JWR.
|
© 2007, The Jewish Ethicist is produced by the JCT Center for Business Ethics
|
