Jewish World Review March 7 , 2012/ 13 Adar, 5772
Program notes, Or: Lutoslawski in Little Roc
By Paul Greenberg
On occasion the exasperated listener, wondering how much longer he'll have to wait for his Bach or
But now all the talk has started to follow the listener right into the concert hall. For it's become customary to introduce the program, sometimes at unfortunate length and in folksy tones. As a conservative, I should be the last to object to custom, that wisest of counselors. Besides, if patience is a virtue, and it is, the opportunity to practice it should be welcomed.
This evening the ever-patient patrons of the local chamber-music series get a short but still much too long introduction, beginning with the most memorable (unfortunately) selection of the evening:
Lutoslawski's String Quartet, a mix of notes and chance in the best/worst modern tradition. As is explained by one of the musicians, "none of us is supposed to play together." For the most part, they succeed.
The talented musicians do their best to slouch toward anarchy but never quite get there. That's the thing about order; it has this way of emerging on its own, as in time and nature and geometry, imposing itself despite our best efforts to upset it. Much like the laws of random selection, which are anything but random.
The musicians wear funereal black, fitting for a work that's not supposed to have a pulse. Are they beginning now, or only tuning up? It isn't clear, a sure indication they're following the composer's instructions.
It's all pretty dreadful but there's a fascination to it. Where'll they go next? Do they know? Does it matter? Just as long as it ends, please God.
No, it's not the sort of thing you might like to hear first thing in the morning on your classical music station. Or anytime. But here in the gleaming Great Hall of the
Witold Lutoslowski sounds like an artist/mathematician who wanted to be the
We're told the piece is supposed to be unpredictable, dramatic, ad hoc ... but, like so many things intended to shock, or at least surprise, it doesn't. It's almost comfortable, conversational, congenial. This noted modernist composer, who's supposed to be so formidable, winds up instead sounding like a nice chap -- someone you'd down a vodka with. But not two.
The musicians do their best to work themselves into a frenzy as instructed but, heck, it's the South, and the lady and gentlemen of the quartet wind up charming instead of alarming us. It can't be helped. Locale is all. Sometimes a composer fails despite the worst of intentions. It's hard to be uncomfortable in such surroundings. But I'm glad I heard the piece. Once.
Much can be forgiven a composer born in
Having seen it all, Witold Lutoslawski would die in
Tedium doesn't set in till almost the end, when at one point the music seems to fall into a swoon, like a P-38 after an unfortunate encounter with a Zero. Indeed, the piece doesn't so much end as it is put out of its misery. You can almost hear, you do hear, the audience sigh with relief. The silence comes like music.
The rest of the program erases the pain, beginning with Grandjany's "Rhapsodie pour la Harpe, Op. 10." After tumult, order. After war, peace. After raving, quiet. After the long night, matins. After slaying his tens of thousands, David plays his harp. After the crusades have raged, the monks pray. There is balance in the world after all, harmony and comfort.
Then comes Torke's "Chalk," a musical equivalent of a pointillist painting in all its pastel shades. The listener may have to stand back before all the dots form a picture. In this case it's pink and rose and gray -- a kind of blended nougat of sound. Delicious. But maybe too rich. Even for someone with a sweet tooth. A wedge of lemon on the salad, please, a dash of salt on the watermelon. Something to cut the sweetness.
The best is saved for the end:
Serioso? Why not Elegante? That adjective would fit as well. Why any description at all? It just gets in the way.
Stately, swaying, the piece resolves not just chords but the evening. Give 'em a happy ending every time.
For that feeling of elation and elevation great music affords, a
Then comes the encore: driving home safely, humming.
JWR contributor Paul Greenberg, editorial page editor of the Arkansas Democrat-Gazette, has won the Pulitzer Prize for editorial writing. Send your comments by clicking here.
if (strpos(, "printer_friendly") === 0)
=<< © 2010 Tribune Media Services, Inc.
© 2010 Tribune Media Services, Inc.