Thursday

March 28th, 2024

On Media

Antifa protesters couldn't find any fascists at Unite the Right --- and harassed the press instead

Antonia Farzan

By Antonia Farzan Avi Selkanti

Published August 14,2018

Antifa protesters couldn't find any fascists at Unite the Right --- and harassed the press instead
  Astride Riecken for The Washington Post
WASHINGTON - Antifascists, according their own doctrine, fight fascism. Sounds simple enough.


Granted, members of the loosely organized Antifa movement define "fascism" vaguely -- to include not just Nazis and neo-Nazis, but also white supremacists, white nationalists and the broader population of racists.


As for the fighting, Antifa takes that part of the doctrine literally. Claiming that even a small public gathering of fascists is a threat to freedom, the movement condones physical violence against them. Its anonymous, black-clad members routinely crash far-right demonstrations to brawl.


So you might expect that when Antifa can't find any fascists, it has nothing to fight. That seemed to be the situation last weekend, when a long-planned rally for far-right extremists fizzled into a paltry gathering of a few dozen white supremacists, unapproachable and nearly invisible behind a police blockade as they met without incident in Washington, D.C., park.


And yet Antifa still managed to fight -- not fascists this time, but reporters.


Sunday's event had been advertised as a sequel to the massive, deadly "Unite the Right" rallies in Charlottesville, Virginia, last year. Organizers had hoped to draw hundreds of racists from across the country, but instead managed to bring fewer than 40 people to Lafayette Square.


By contrast, thousands of protesters surrounded the park to shout the racists down and drown out their speeches.


A few blocks away, several dozen masked Antifa members marched up 13th Street in the early afternoon. They carried the movement's red-and-black flag, and some wore makeshift body armor even though no fascists where anywhere in sight.


When a Washington Post reporter tried to interview the antifascists, they refused to speak. When he followed them up the street with his cellphone camera, one of them shoved a black umbrella into his lens and several shouted, "No photos!"


"This can harm us," one of the protesters said, just before someone swatted the reporter's iPhone out of his hand and threw it into the middle of the street.


The reporter and camera were fine, but the incident was hardly isolated. Throughout the day, journalists covering the rally shared stories of cameras being yanked and reporters accosted by members of the same movement that claims it is protecting free society.


At the same event, NPR reporter Tim Mak watched Antifa protesters lob fireworks and bottles at the police separating them from the white supremacists.


Then he ducked as someone whipped an egg at his head.


Mak noted that Antifa's showing was dwarfed by thousands of other people who peacefully protested the white supremacists. "I was not marked as press," he wrote, "and have no reason to believe it was thrown at me because I am a reporter."


But other videos show Antifa members accosting reporters specifically because they're reporters, in scenes reminiscent of Donald Trump campaign rallies where the press was often treated as enemy.


"Are you going to report how many people they teargassed?" a self-described Antifa member screams at two reporters, as seen in video published by the right-wing website Breitbart.


"Of course I will," a photographer replies. "That's what I'm doing."


A man in a bandanna lunges into the camera frame, screaming expletives at the journalists.


"Ask questions!" the woman scolds them. "Don't just keep taking pictures."


"We do both!" says a woman who identified herself as a USA Today reporter. "I'm just trying to do my job, man."


It was a similar scene in Charlottesville, which spent the weekend marking the first anniversary since a woman was killed while protesting a massive gathering of white nationalists.


Few if any white nationalists were on display there last weekend. But Antifa came nonetheless.

By sundown on Saturday, NBC reporter Cal Perry wrote, the University of Virginia students who had organized Saturday's protests against white supremacy had already left the day by then.


"Almost exclusively #Antifa at that point," he wrote, and posted video of a man with a kerchief around his neck, screaming "Snitch ass news b--!" and slapping his TV crew's phone away.


On Sunday, a reporter for the local ABC Station WTVD shared video of Antifa members shoving objects into his crew's camera lens -- then cutting their microphone cord.


The anti-media hostility was even on display in Canada, where a group "Intersectional Anti-Fascists" marched against Islamophobia and yelled at a Toronto Sun journalist. Then a man took a swipe at the newspaper's videographer.


Antifa's anti-fascist aggression has morphed into attacks on the press before. Members of the movement were documented threatening reporters and smashing cameras during protests in Berkeley, Calif.ornia, last year, for example.


But normally, brawls between antifascists and racists get most of the attention. In the aftermath of this weekend's rallies, Antifa's attacks on the press stood out.


Antifa was condemned not only by right-wing commentators (several of whom found ways to criticize the mainstream media for not sufficiently covering the attacks), but by prominent national reporters such as CNN's Jake Tapper and Brian Stelter.


The press being the press, reactions varied, of course. Daily Beast reporter Kelly Weill argued that the vast majority of antifascists in Washington last weekend "were pretty uniformly chill."

Columnists

Toons