Jewish World Review

You Choose

By Rabbi Binyomin Ginsberg



It's increasingly more common for parents to become so concerned about the rights of children that they allow their sons and daughters to be harmed

Advice from a seasoned educator and avowed traditionalist

http://www.JewishWorldReview.com | After touring the school, the prospective parents expressed how enthusiastic they were with what they observed. What I was sure was to be followed by a request for an application turned out to be something that took me by surprise.


"We will now go home and discuss the choices and options with our son and we will get back to you."


What astonished me was the fact that the child was entering kindergarten. Yes! Parents were having a 5-year-old make such a monumental decision!


This attitude is representative of an aspect of today's society that believes it is healthy and important for children to make their own choices. These parents are so concerned about the rights of children that they allow their children to possibly be harmed in the process.


Little do they realize the dangers ahead!


I also believe that it is healthy for children to make choices. However, I differ with the types of choices that children should be allowed and be asked to make. This article will address several guidelines we can follow of what kinds of choices our children are to make and how to set the stage for our children to make good choices.


Enabling our child to make the correct choices is quite a challenge. Parents must know when to make the decision for the child and when to allow a child to make his own decision and then live with the consequences of a possible poor choice. There is a distant difference between a parent who allows the child to make too many choices and a parent who doesn't allow the child to make any choices at all.


One of the most important tools parents should give their child is the skill of how to make good decisions. That can only be learned with practice. However, we must present children with appropriate choices with which to practice. While learning, mistakes will be made. The child will look to the parent for reassurance that his choice is good. Give the child choices that won't have a dramatic negative result if a wrong choice is made.


The child who comes to the parent to make ALL of the decisions lacks self-confidence. That is a signal to parents to allow or even require the child to experiment with choices. Parents must realize that not allowing the child to make ANY choices is detrimental. A controlling parent is laying the groundwork for increasing the chances of raising a rebellious child.


Everyone, even babies, want some control in their lives. An infant knows the effects of a smile or friendly gesture to an adult. That infant also knows that crying can bring certain results. The child cries and the parent draws near with a different object in each hand. Without saying anything, the parent can ask the child which object he wants. The child can make a choice without any verbal communication by pointing to or taking hold of the desired item.


In deciding whether or not to allow your child to make a choice, focus on the goal. If the goal is a parent spending time with a child, provide the child with a choice of either dad reading a story to you or playing Legos with you. These are both acceptable and support the goal of spending time together.


When providing a child with an opportunity to make choices, it is critical that the child be provided with adequate information to make that choice. While it is healthy to allow some choices to be made by the child, too much choosing and in the wrong areas can be disadvantageous. It may cause confusion and the child may lose confidence in his ability to make choices. For example, giving a child the choice to do homework or play a game is setting the child up for failure. The child is not equipped to deal with the temptation. Helping the child develop a list of pros and cons for choices helps the child make good decisions.


Before giving our children the opportunity for making choices, it is advisable to show how we, as adults, make choices. Discussing several appropriate choices you have been faced with and explaining the process by which you arrived at a decision, is a marvelous tool.


In introducing children to making choices, it is best to limit the number of options from which to choose. For example, if you would like to give your child a choice as to what clothes to wear, it is best to just give the child two or three options. Opening the closet and offering the child to choose from the entire display can be too overwhelming. As much as our present-day culture indicates that children wish to make choices, I found strong evidence to the contrary in my school.


As I researched this issue, I offered children a chance to make some choices. The overwhelming majority of the children put the choice back in my court. Children look to adults for guidance. Limiting the number of choices and offering quality options help the child be successful in the decision-making process.


While the parents should make most important choices, involving the child with the decision-making process in some manner is vital for the successful acceptance of the choice made by the parents. On many occasions I have been asked for specific guidelines on what choices children of certain ages should be able encouraged allowed to make.


In making sure that we raise each child according to his needs it is really impossible to set all the guidelines. While in most situations, a child of high-school age should have input as to which high school to attend, there are exceptions. Determining which choices children should make really requires us to first know the child and the strengths and weaknesses of the child.


An important skill that we must teach our children is how to deal with the outcome of a poor choice. If there are negative consequences, it is usually best to allow the child to suffer the consequence and the parent should not cover up or handle the consequence. Making wrong choices and learning from them is a critical step in the process of maturing.


Although parents may say — and believe — that they are allowing their child free choice, they may often (sometimes inadvertently) send the child subtle signals via body language, word choice, and facial expressions that influence the child's decision. Children are very sensitive to the non-verbal messages they receive and a child may submerge his true wishes in order to please his parents. Parents must be careful to avoid such manipulative behavior, since it may negatively impact the emotional growth of the child. At times, children become so dependent on the approval of their parents that later in life they are unable to make important decisions independently.


In summary, there is no clear and definitive guideline that tells us which choices to allow children to make and when to allow them choices. It is ultimately the parents' call to determine which decisions the child should be allowed to make. As in all parenting issues, praying to the Almighty for the right His assistance is effective.


GAINED FROM THIS ESSAY?

YOU CAN BUY THE BOOK

Click HERE to purchase it at a discount. (Sales help fund JWR.).