|
|
|
Jewish World Review June 29, 2005 / 22 Sivan, 5765 Making parking lots out of ‘castles’ By John Stossel
http://www.JewishWorldReview.com |
Think your house is your castle? Our country's Founders thought
so. They put three provisions into the Bill of Rights to protect it.
But last week, the Supreme Court said the government can take
away your house just because it thinks someone else could make better use of
your home or business than you can.
The justification? The Constitution does recognize that there
are public needs, such as building roads, so vital the government must be
able to take your land. It says the government may take property, but only
for a "public use" and with "just compensation."
The phrase at the center of last week's case is "public use."
It's an important phrase, because it's supposed to mean that the government
can only use force to take your property in order to do its job. The
government, which is supposed to stop criminals from driving you off your
land, isn't supposed to get to force you off your land just because some
official thinks someone else will put the land to "better" use.
I once brought ABC's cameras to a neighborhood in New Rochelle,
N.Y., that politicians decided to flatten to make room for an Ikea furniture
outlet. The mayor boasted that a new store would replace a "blighted"
neighborhood. Blighted? It was a perfectly nice group of homes and
businesses.
I like Ikea stores. But let them build them on their own
property.
Why should homeowners be forced out? Why do the politicians get
to decide? The people who lived in the neighborhood couldn't believe what
was happening to them. As one woman said, "What freedom do we have when we
have businesses that will just come in and say, 'Oh, you have to move'?" But
businesses can't force anyone to move. Only government gets to use force;
Ikea was just the favored business that day. The government had decided that
selling furniture was a "public use": "urban renewal" that would be "good
for the community."
Said Dana Berliner, a lawyer for the libertarian law firm
Institute for Justice, "It's always what the 'community' wants. The
'community' wants to be more upscale. It figures it can get there by
sacrificing some of its members, forcing them to move when they don't want
to." Fortunately, the New Rochelle homeowners were able to keep their
property. Ikea and the politicians backed down after the publicity.
Donald Trump wasn't so easy. In the early Nineties, he wanted to
expand one of his casinos in Atlantic City.
Vera Coking was in the way. The elderly widow had lived in a
house in Atlantic City for more than 30 years, and she didn't want to move.
So New Jersey's Casino Reinvestment Development Authority sued to "acquire"
Coking's property.
He replied: "Other people maybe use thugs today. I don't." True
enough. Trump didn't send thugs after Coking; he sent the government. That's
worse. If he had sent thugs, Coking could have called the police. But when
government forces you out of your home so that some other private person can
pave it, whom are you going to call?
Trump wanted to turn Coking's home into a parking lot. The court
accepted the bureaucrats' decision that the parking lot would be a "public
use" but rejected Trump's bid, saying Trump's private benefit "overwhelmed"
the public benefit. Justice Stevens, in his opinion for the Court last week,
uses a similar notion when he claims that the purpose of taking your land to
give it to some well-connected corporation must still be a public one, such
as improving the economy; merely benefiting a company isn't good enough.
But as Justice O'Connor pointed out in her dissent, if you can
think of a more economically productive use for your home, you'd better
worry. If a politician thinks of it, your castle may not be yours any
longer.
Every weekday JewishWorldReview.com publishes what many in in the media and Washington consider "must-reading". Sign up for the daily JWR update. It's free. Just click here.
© 2005, by JFS Productions, Inc. Distributed by Creators Syndicate, Inc. |
Mitch Albom | ||||||||||||
