Home
In this issue
Nov. 20, 2009
Rabbi David Aaron: How to make every second of your life come first
Caroline B. Glick: Whither American Jewry
Nov. 19, 2009
Binyamin L. Jolkovsky: Please Listen to this Godcast (5 minutes)
Jonathan Tobin: ADL Crosses the Line with Report Bashing Obama Critics
Nov. 18, 2009
Rabbi Yonason Goldson: What Judaism has to say about the secret of the Mona Lisa's smile
JWisdom.com: The (Jewish) Dating Game with Rabbi Lawrence Hajioff (8 minutes)
Nov. 17, 2009
Steven Emerson: How Does the 4th Amendment Impact Terror Finance Investigations?
JWisdom.com: If Frank Sinatra married Edith Piaf with Rabbi Y.Y. Rubinstein (2 minutes) Life lessons from what would be regarded as the most inappropriate lyrics ever sung
Nov. 16, 2009
The Jewish Ethicist by Rabbi Dr. Asher Meir : When borrowing is stealing
JWisdom.com: Deconstructing faith with Rabbi Warren Goldstein (9 minutes)
Nov. 13, 2009
JWisdom.com Sarah's subjective reality with Rabbi Sroy Levitansky ( 6 minutes)
Caroline B. Glick: Obama's failure, Netanyahu's opportunity
Nov. 12, 2009
The Kosher Gourmet By Marialisa Calta : A sweet sweet potato treat
JWisdom.com Does God get tired? with Rabbi Harvey Belovski ( 5 minutes)
Nov. 11, 2009
Rabbi Avi Shafran: Jews and money: When anti-Semitism isn't
JWisdom.com Marriages are not made in Heaven with Rabbi Lawrence Hajioff (VERY fast 15 minutes)
Nov. 10, 2009
Michael Doyle: Author of book exposing CAIR ordered to remove supporting documents from Web
JWisdom.com If the creation so loudly shouts the existence of the Creator, why aren't more people believers? with Rabbi Naftali Brawer (9 minutes)
Nov. 9, 2009
Mark Steyn: Shooter exposes hole in U.S. terror strategy
JWisdom.com It's never too late to have a happy childhood with Sarah Chana Radcliffe (5 minutes)
Nov. 6, 2009
Rabbi Berel Wein: Choosing to hear
JWisdom.com Zero to 1/60th: How to Empower An Hour with Gavriel Aryeh Sande (7 minutes)
Caroline B. Glick The mullahs' big week
Suzanne Fields A Fallen Wall for Fallen Man
Nov. 5, 2009
The Kosher Gourmet: Three scrumptious -- but simple -- butternut squash dishes
JWisdom.com Hidden Hints: Unlocking Faith & Prayer with Rabbi Jay Yaacov Schwartz (10 minutes)
Nov. 4, 2009
Tom Hamburger and Kim Geiger: Should prayers be covered?
JWisdom.com When God played peacemaker With Rabbi Sroy Levitansky (5 minutes)
Nov. 3, 2009
Martin Peretz: Beware, Barack. Beware, Rahm. Beware, Axelrod
JWisdom.com Are you are closet idolater? With Sara Yoheved Rigler (10 minutes)
Nov. 2, 2009
Paul Greenberg: The Holocaust is now on Facebook
JWisdom.com Abraham's Strange Change With Rabbi Yitzchok Fingerer (5 minutes)
Oct. 29, 2003
Mortimer B. Zuckerman: Graffiti On History's Walls (MUST-READ!)

Jewish World Review June 24, 2005 / 17 Sivan, 5765

Military Service and the Founding Fathers

By Drs. Michael A. Glueck & Robert J. Cihak

The Medicine Men
Printer Friendly Version
Email this article

http://www.JewishWorldReview.com | Some issues just don't go away. That's because they tell us, not just what to do or avoid, but what kind of people we are.

The draft is such an issue. More specifically: All the volunteers who aren't there. The Army now expects to miss its 80,000 person recruiting goal for this fiscal year, perhaps by 10,000 or more, even after easing qualification requirements and increasing enlistment bonuses. Some conservatives hold that the administration simply hasn't done a very good job of selling the war that came out of Iraq's liberation; others contend that young Americans are simply too self-centered to serve.

Neither is exactly true. What is certain is that so long as recruiting continues badly and the war goes on, the Army's predicament will only worsen. Our purpose here, however, is not to argue for or against the war, or for or against the draft. Our purpose is to provide a bit of historical context for assessing the whole relationship between citizenship and military service.


BUY THE BOOK
Does this book sound intriguing?

HERE to purchase it at a discount. (Sales help fund JWR.).

Twenty years ago, Philip Gold, a historian, defense analyst and former Marine, published "Evasions: the American Way of Military Service." His book in progress, "Gone for Soldiers," revisits this issue. One thing he feels is much in need of revisiting: the Founding Fathers' understanding of military service.

To the Founders military service was both an obligation and a right of citizenship. It was also a profound test of the virtue of the citizenry. A people unwilling to bear arms in the common defense was not a people fit for republican self-government.

However, the Founders never intended that this right and obligation should provide the federal government with a blank check on the lives of the citizens. The structure they set up does the exact opposite.

According to Gold, the Founders derived their understanding from both tradition and experience. From the Greeks and Romans through the Middle Ages, custom and law held that a citizen or free subject had an unlimited obligation to participate in homeland defense — but in comparison only a limited obligation, and sometimes no obligation at all, to participate in "wars of choice" beyond borders. This was true throughout the pre-revolutionary period. Every colony save Quaker Pennsylvania considered virtually all adult (back then, free white male) members as part of the "universal" or "unorganized" militia. Some would join the organized militia, assembling periodically to drink, drill, tell stories, drill, then drink some more. For extended or distant campaigns, a special volunteer militia would usually be raised.

Donate to JWR


The Revolutionary War demonstrated that the militia had limited value against regular armies. If the Founders clung to this ideal, it was not because they didn't learn this hard lesson. Nor was it merely a paranoid fear of "standing armies" and "men on horseback." Rather, they understood defense to be a continuum, with individual and local self-defense against crime and disorder at one end, proceeding to defense against insurrection and invasion, thence to foreign wars of choice conducted by the federal government. The citizen-soldiery could function across this entire spectrum while maintaining a precious nexus between government and citizenry: The soldiers would be available, but the reasons for fighting had to be sufficient to convince the citizens before they were called upon to be soldiers.

The Constitution nowhere mentions federal conscription, although the "Federalist" and a century's worth of Supreme Court decisions affirm that conscription is a legitimate aspect of providing for the common defense.

However, this original omission can't be understood without reference to the Militia Act of 1791. This legislation, ancestor of the present National Guard system, mandated universal obligatory service at the state level, with state forces available to the federal government in time of specific emergency. All else was to be handled by the standing army or by volunteer forces raised for a clear and limited purpose.

"That's the vital nexus between the citizenry and the government in this matter," says Gold. "An absolute obligation to serve, but not to serve for any and all reasons. This nexus has a moral as well as a legal dimension. Things that are legal are not always moral or wise. Faith can be shattered in many ways."

Vietnam harmed the nexus between citizenship and conscription that had existed since World War II. America assumed, wrongly, that draftees could be sent anywhere to do anything. And now, Iraq has harmed the nexus between obligation and the National Guard and reserves in the same manner. While conscript and reserve forces must be available in extremis, they cannot be used and over-used, year after year, militarily or morally.

Not without the consent of We the People — a consent that must go much deeper than opinion polls or Congressional resolutions, if it is to avail.

Editor's Note: Michael Arnold Glueck, M.D., penned this week's commentary.

Every weekday JewishWorldReview.com publishes what many in in the media and Washington consider "must-reading". Sign up for the daily JWR update. It's free. Just click here.

Michael Arnold Glueck, M.D., is a multiple award winning writer who comments on medical-legal issues. Robert J. Cihak, M.D., is a Discovery Institute Senior Fellow and a past president of the Association of American Physicians and Surgeons. Both JWR contributors are Harvard trained diagnostic radiologists. Comment by clicking here.

Archives

© 2005,

Insight (Our Columnists)

 Arnold Ahlert
 Mitch Albom
 Michael Barone
  Dave Barry
 Tony Blankley
 Andy Borowitz
 David Broder
 Stratfor Briefing
 Mona Charen
 Linda Chavez
 Ann Coulter
 Greg Crosby
 Larry Elder
 Suzanne Fields
 John Fund
 Frank J. Gaffney
 Lloyd Garver
 Jonah Goldberg
 Julia Gorin
 Jonathan Gurwitz
 Paul Greenberg
 Lewis Grossberger
 Victor Davis Hanson
 Betsy Hart
 Nat Hentoff
 David Horowitz
 Laura Ingraham
 Cheri Jacobus
Jeff Jacoby
 Paul Johnson
 Jack Kelly
 Ed Koch
 Ch. Krauthammer
 Michael Ledeen
 John Leo
 David Limbaugh
 Kathryn Lopez
 Rich Lowry
 Michelle Malkin
 Jackie Mason
 Dick Morris
 Bill O'Reilly
 Jim Mullen
 Clarence Page
 Kathleen Parker
 Dennis Prager
 Wesley Pruden
 Tom Purcell
 Jonathan Rauch
 Celia Rivenbark
 Robert Robb
 Cokie & Steve Roberts
 Pat Sajak
 Debra J. Saunders
 Culture Shlock
 Roger Simon
 Michael Smerconish
 Thomas Sowell
 Mark Steyn
 John Stossel
 Cal Thomas
 Bob Tyrrell
 Diana West
 Dave Weinbaum
 George Will
 Walter Williams
 Byron York
 Mort Zuckerman

'Toons
 Robert Arial
 Chuck Asay
 Baloo
 Chip Bok
 Dry Bones
  Lisa Benson
 John Branch
 Gary Brookins
 John Cole
 J. D. Crowe
 John Deering
 Brian Duffy
 Everything's Relative
 Mallard Fillmore
 Jake Fuller
 Bob Gorrel
 Joe Heller
 David Hitch
 Jerry Holber
 Steve Kelley
 Jeff Koterba
 Dick Locher
 Chan Lowe
 Ranan R. Lurie
 Jimmy Margulies
 Rick McKee
 Michael Ramirez
 Kevin Siers
 Jeff Stahler
 Ed Stein
 Danna Summers
 John Trever
 Gary Varvel
 Kirk Walters

Lifestyles
 How 2
 Lori Borgman
 The Savvy Consumer
 Elder matters
 Fixit
 Dr. Peter Gott
 GET A JOB! by Marty Nemko
 Richard Lederer
 Tech Maven
 Every Monday Matters
 Nutrition Myths
 Bookmark These
 Bruce Williams
 How Stuff Works