Contact The Editor
Articles By This Author
The Turkish government is obviously familiar with the concept of "chutzpah," if not necessarily the word.
Ankara summoned the American ambassador to protest allegedly "aggressive and unprofessional actions" by the Washington, DC, police. Their offense? Intervening after Turkish security personnel mauled peaceful protesters outside the Turkish ambassador's residence in Washington last week.
Video of the incident is jaw-dropping. About a dozen people protested Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan - arriving at the ambassador's residence after a White House visit - from a safe distance across the street.
A safe distance, it turned out, for Erdogan, not the demonstrators. His guards suddenly rushed en masse past the DC cops to beat up the demonstrators.
The neutral language of press accounts can obscure the truth of what happened. The two sides didn't "clash" or "engage in a violent confrontation," as is often reported. There was a clear aggressor - the thuggish security personnel of the head of state of, amazingly enough, a NATO country.
The guards repeatedly kicked a man who had been thrown to the ground in the face. They put a woman in a headlock. Dressed in black suits, they behaved like drunken British soccer hooligans or antifa agitators. Clearly, assaulting innocent people is a core competency.
This incident, which injured 11, is not the most consequential event in the world. It's not the Syrian war, or a North Korean missile test.
We have large national interests at stake with Turkey, especially in navigating the complex currents in the Syria civil war. But it's not nothing, either. It deserves more than State Department statements of "concern."
Especially given the context. The guards didn't lash out on their own. They charged under the watchful eye of President Erdogan, who was sitting in a black Mercedes Benz and emerged to observe the assault. The Daily Caller contends, based on audio analysis, that Erdogan himself may have given the order for the attack.
This is the second offense for the Turks. A year ago, they beat up protesters and disfavored journalists outside an Erdogan talk at the Brookings
Institution in Washington. One reporter wrote of that earlier incident, "never seen anything like this." If you hang around President Erdogan long enough, though, you'll see it all.
Erodgan is a thug who has bullied, cheated and purged his way to the head of a budding authoritarian state, accumulating powers unparalleled since Attaturk.
It speaks to the nature of his regime that Turkish officials insist the guards acted in "self defense."
William F. Buckley Jr. once said this kind of reasoning "is the equivalent of saying that the man who pushes an old lady into the path of a hurtling bus is not to be distinguished from the man who pushes an old lady out of the path of a hurtling bus: on the grounds that, after all, in both cases someone is pushing old ladies around."
The Trump administration is obviously not putting an emphasis on promoting our values abroad. But it's one thing not to go on a democratizing crusade; it's another to shrug off an assault on the rights of protesters on our own soil.
If nothing else, President Trump's nationalism and sense of honor should be offended. Not only did the Turks carry out this attack, they are thumbing their noses at us by summoning our ambassador over it.
The Turkish goons who punched and kicked people should be identified and charged with crimes. They are beyond our reach, either because they're back in Turkey or have diplomatic immunity. But we should ask for them to be returned and for their immunity to be waived. When these requests are inevitably refused, the Turkish ambassador to the United States (heard saying during the incident, "you cannot touch us") should be expelled.
Erdogan is crushing his opponents with impunity in Turkey. Reacting firmly to this attack at least will send the message, "Not in our house."
Comment by clicking here.