Jewish World Review May 4, 2012/ 12 Iyar, 5772
Libs want to plunge the penthouse
By Deroy Murdock
http://www.JewishWorldReview.com | "Every time a bank fails an angel gets its wings." So goes a graffito in Manhattan's East Village. One block away, as marchers occupied Broadway on May Day, their picket signs pleaded, "Millionaires must pay their fair share," and, "No free ride for Wall Street."
These words echo Occupy Wall Street and its spiritual leader, President Barack Obama. Class warriors scream about imposing "fairness" on the rich, but their shouts become mumbles when asked what precise tax rate achieves "fairness."
Liberals grow mum amid these facts: In 2009, the latest IRS figures demonstrate, the much-maligned top 1 percent of taxpayers earned 17 percent of national income and paid 37 percent of federal income taxes. The top 10 percent made 43 percent of income and surrendered 70.5 percent of income-tax revenues. Meanwhile, the bottom 50 percent scored 13.5 percent of income and paid just 2.3 percent of income taxes.
Unfair? If so, the Left should specify what heavier tax burden on the wealthy or lighter tax load on the lower half of taxpayers would trigger "fairness."
"Fairness" hardly involves augmenting tax revenues, either for debt relief or even the social spending that makes liberals salivate.
As the Ethics and Public Policy Center's Peter Wehner recalled April 12 in a superb CommentaryMagazine.com essay, then-Sen. Obama advocated a higher capital-gains tax rate, although lowering it from 28 percent to 20 in 1997 actually expanded net revenues by 124 percent from $54 billion in fiscal 1996 to $121 billion in fiscal 2000. That levy was chopped by Tea Party pin-up, William Jefferson Clinton.
"Well, Charlie," Obama told ABC's Charlie Gibson in 2008, "what I've said is that I would look at raising the capital-gains tax for purposes of fairness."
For too many liberals like Obama, "fairness" is not about enriching the modest; it's about impoverishing the moneyed.
Financier Warren Buffet has energized liberals with his still-unverified claim that his tax rate lags his secretary's. If true, "fairness" could mean slashing his secretary's taxes to match Buffet's 11 percent effective tax rate. Somehow, reducing the secretary's taxes never came up. Instead liberals and Democrats demand the so-called Buffet Rule, an instrument for bludgeoning the successful rather than boosting the downtrodden.
In her final appearance before the British House of Commons, former Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher skewered this liberal mindset. Feisty as ever, she answered her colleagues' questions on the gap between the needy and the affluent.
"The honorable gentleman is saying that he would rather that the poor were poorer, provided that the rich were less rich," Thatcher explained on Nov. 22, 1990. "So long as the gap is smaller, they would rather have the poor poorer. One does not create wealth and opportunity that way."
Like Thatcher, American conservatives should reject the income gap. Who cares about the gap, provided that those on the bottom advance in absolute terms?
Consider two job offers: a) you earn $50,000, while your boss makes $55,000, just 10 percent more. b) You earn $500,000, while your employer gets $1 million - twice your salary. "Unfairness" suddenly looks spectacular.
Here's how the Right should challenge the Left:
If you dislike income inequality, lift those with the least. Let's adopt universal school choice, allow personal Social Security retirement accounts (to democratize long-term capital accumulation), radically reduce or eliminate America's anti-competitive, 35 percent corporate tax (to supercharge businesses), and pass Right-to-Work laws (so, the jobless won't fester outside closed shops). Let's build the Keystone Pipeline (to create 20,000 blue-collar positions RIGHT NOW and lower everyone's energy prices), frack for natural gas, and tame the Environmental Protection Agency, Occupational Safety and Health Administration, Securities and Exchange Commission and other power-mad bureaucracies, so U.S. companies stay here and foreign firms move in.
If liberals agree, they should enact this economic-growth agenda. If not, they should explain why they reject these proposals to help poor people prosper.
Most likely, the ensuing silence would reveal liberals' true intentions: Not to lift the lobby, but to plunge the penthouse.
Every weekday JewishWorldReview.com publishes what many in in the media and Washington consider "must-reading". Sign up for the daily JWR update. It's free. Just click here.
Comment by clicking here.
Deroy Murdock is a columnist with Scripps Howard News Service and a media fellow with the Hoover Institution on War, Revolution and Peace at Stanford University.
• 04/27/12: Obama and company are pushing hard on the pedal for deadlier cars
• 04/20/12: We don't need no stinkin' budget?
• 04/14/12: New Reasons to Hate Obamacare
• 04/06/12: Team Obama plays energy policy for laughs
• 03/30/12: Twitchy Dems need to let workers put tax-cut money in retirement funds
• 03/23/12: Why not $100-an-hour minimum wage?
• 03/15/12: The real (high) cost of Obama's health care act
• 03/09/12: Race-baiting Dems oppose voter ID
• 03/02/12: Forget kids --- today's debt hurts adults
• 02/24/12: Dems arise against Obamacare
• 02/17/12: The voting dead are understated
• 02/10/12: Holder takes on 'racist' photo-ID cards: Prejudice is widespread --- even Obama backed them
• 02/03/12: On tax plans, Gingrich trumps Romney
• 01/27/12: Photo IDs can protect elections, let dead rest
• 01/20/12: Romney runs hot and cold on global warming
• 01/13/12: Economic freedom declines in U.S.
• 01/06/12: Time to yank off Mitt's mask
• 12/23/11: Boehner hands Dems a gift
• 12/15/11: The U.S. could learn much from Hong Kong
• 12/09/11:$687 billion is available to Congress free of strings
• 12/02/11: Obama criticizes Wall Street but takes money from it
• 11/18/11: Puerto Rico shows Washington the way
• 11/11/11: Take heed, America: In Ohio even left-wing unionists voted to repeal ObamaCare
• 10/28/11: Thanks, Netanyahu, for surge of hardened terrorists
• 10/24/11:The Obama Spend-O-Rama
• 10/17/11: Cain stakes his viable claim just by showing up
• 10/07/11: Green jobs are national scandal
• 10/04/11: Obama proudly declares class war
• 09/23/11: Obama wrong about Do-Nothing Congress
• 09/16/11: Obama needs Ryan's vision on jobs
• 09/09/11: Reaganomics trounces Obamanomics
• 09/02/11: Labor leaders to Obama: Stop killing jobs
• 08/26/11: Pro-market Perry vaults over Romney in GOP race
• 08/19/11: Some rich Americans will not rest until Washington boosts their taxes
• 08/12/11: Hope, change and free birth control for all
• 08/05/11: Debt deal does virtually nothing
• 07/21/11: Dems pro-choice on abortion but little else
• 07/15/11: Debt deception: If only Dems were honest and GOPers were courageous
• 07/08/11: Congress' war on light bulb blows up
© 2011, SCRIPPS HOWARD NEWS SERVICE