Jewish World Review March 14, 2011 / 9 Adar II, 5771
NPR Loses in Gotcha, But What Was Won?
By Mitch Albom
Apparently not. When this happened to
I've heard about liberal guilt. But whatever happened to fighting back?
The sleazeball behind this latest "gotcha" incident is
Thus he sent his operatives to a lunch posing as Muslim charity workers. Posing, as in faking. They offered to make a phony
Schiller, who clearly said he was speaking as an individual, not an
But when the edited comments were released, chaos ensued. The right wing screamed it was evidence that public broadcasting should be de-funded. The left distanced itself from Schiller's "inappropriate" remarks.
And nobody asked the obvious question:
• When did this become journalism?
• Why so little criticism of O'Keefe?
Let's get a few things straight. I'm not here to defend or attack public broadcasting. That's a debate for another day.
But there used to be certain rules for reporting. No matter what your opinion of a subject, you did not pretend to be a person you were not. You didn't give a fake name or a fake workplace. You didn't hide cameras and mikes during phony conversations.
Yes, investigative journalists might fade into the background and war correspondents might keep their identities quiet for safety reasons.
But having a private lunch with a businessman -- totally as a setup to trap him? This isn't "Serpico." You're not cops on a sting.
And yet this "Punk'd" version of news is now so accepted, no one makes nearly the stink about O'Keefe as they do about his victim. Supporters say O'Keefe revealed the true liberal bias of
Well, besides the fact that Schiller was a fundraiser, not a news exec, and the business and editorial sides of public broadcasting are notably separate, let me ask you this. You're a salesman. A big customer makes a dirty joke. Do you lecture him -- or just laugh along because deep down you need the sale? You're a business owner, and a customer turns the conversation political. Do you stop and make a stand? Or do you maybe utter a few agreements and later, on the way home, tell yourself, "I didn't even mean that."
WHEN THE TABLES ARE TURNED
Well, now imagine that those moments were recorded and smeared across the world. Wouldn't your first reaction be, "Hey. That guy was a fraud! And that was private!"
Of course you would. But when it's someone else, we prefer to say, "Aha!"
We'd better be careful if what passes for journalism becomes nothing more than dogmatic espionage. It's the cheapest, laziest form of news -- hide a camera and call it a story. There's no context. No thoroughness. Just "watch this and get shocked."
Every weekday JewishWorldReview.com publishes what many in the media and Washington consider "must-reading". Sign up for the daily JWR update. It's free. Just click here.
© 2011, THE DETROIT FREE PRESS DISTRIBUTED BY TMS, INC.