Tuesday

April 16th, 2024

Nation

Is the conventional wisdom that 'Trump is a failure' merely reflecting a womyn v. men-centric outlook? A cross-cultural glance

Eugene Scott

By Eugene Scott The Washington Post

Published Jan. 22, 2018

 Is the conventional wisdom that 'Trump is a failure' merely reflecting a <I>womyn</I> v. men-centric outlook?  A cross-cultural glance
Thousands of women across the country marked the anniversary of President Donald Trump's inauguration at rallies, marches and protests to remind the administration that many women still believe that his vision of a great America does not include them.

Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand, D-N.Y., who is often discussed as a potential 2020 presidential candidate, told the crowd, "It is women who are holding our democracy together in these dangerous times."

And Emily Patton, a spokeswoman for the march, told The Washington Post:

"This year, we really want to show support for women who are running for office and to encourage more women, women of color and those in the LGBT community, to run for office, to register to vote, to be more civically engaged."

But while Trump is still struggling to win women - a demographic won by his Democratic opponent Hillary Clinton in 2016 - recent approval polls show that men seem to be increasingly on the Trump train.

Most men - 52 percent - voted for Trump in the presidential election, according to exit polls. Some found his "strong man" image attractive and supported him pushing back against what his supporters call "political correctness" in a cultural climate that is becoming increasingly vocal about the impact of patriarchy.

As critics of Trump continue to vocalize their belief that his policies disadvantage women, some men's support of him grows.

A recent CNN poll revealed that Trump's approval rating among men had improved eight points. Nearly half - 49 percent - of American men approve of the job Trump is doing.

And in a cumulative analysis of more than 600,000 SurveyMonkey interviews about Trump's job performance, some of Trump's better numbers are with men.

Nearly half - 49 percent - of white millennial men without a college degree approve of the president's performance. And Trump's support has risen among blue-collar white men over 35.

And even among some subgroups where Trump is doing poorly, like black Americans, Trump receives higher approval marks from men. According to the Atlantic:

"Among African Americans and Hispanics, reactions to Trump depend more on gender than age or education. In every age group, and at every level of education, about twice as many African American men as women gave Trump positive marks. In all, 23 percent of black men approved of Trump's performance versus 11 percent of black women. . . . Black men are one of the few groups for which Trump's 2017 average approval rating significantly exceeds his 2016 vote share.

Among Hispanics, men were also much more likely than women to express positive views about Trump. Among Hispanic men older than 50, Trump's approval - strikingly - exceeded 40 percent."

Conservative commentator Charlie Sykes told the Washington Post that quite a few men feel as if Trump is speaking for their concerns in a world where few are.

"A lot of blue collar men think they are living in an increasingly feminized world and Donald Trump represents to them unabashed, unapologetic masculinity - an in-your-face refusal to give in to political correctness or the politics of 'sensitivity.' They think he fights for them, as opposing to judging or preaching at them. And he makes the right enemies - football players who won't kneel, black female congresswomen, Hollywood elites, and the media.

They may not fully embrace his vulgarity, his insults or his brutishness, but they like the attitude. And, increasingly politics is not about issues or policies as much as it is about striking the right attitude."

Previously:
11/22/17: Don't forget about the men who said they've been sexually assaulted, too
11/17/17: Decades after Bill Clinton allegations, Dems have a chance to finally get it right

Columnists

Toons